Shows    »   The Buck Stops Here    »  It's up to Sonia
NDTV
Barkha Dutt The Buck Stops Here, a show that brings you the big interviews, debates, all the election news and of course the very latest from our turbulent neighbours. If it matters, we've got it covered on this show.

Congress leader Jagdish Tytler has been asked by the party to withdraw his candidature from the Lok Sabha elections. "I will not pursue my candidature for this election. I have left it to the Congress president to decide. I don't want to embarrass the party," Tytler said.

The 1984 riots case has always been an emotive issue in Punjab; it flared up few days ago when the CBI gave a clean chit to Congress leaders Jagdish Tytler and Sajjan Kumar – accused of inciting a mob that killed hundreds of Sikhs after Indira Gandhi’s assassination in 1984.

On Tuesday, a journalist added fuel to fire when he threw a shoe at Home Minister P Chidambaram during a press conference over the CBI clean chit. So, we ask, is the Congress' credibility on 1984 hanging by a shoestring?

On the Buck Stops Here, join Barkha Dutt for a discussion on NDTV 24x7.
What's your take?
Q.Is the Congress’ credibility on 1984 hanging by a shoestring?

Yes

No

Can't say
Recent Highlights
Indians outcast in the outback?
Indians outcast in the outback?
Rahul Bhatt: The Headley story
Rahul Bhatt: The Headley story
Uddhav's Sena: On the warpath?
Uddhav's Sena: On the warpath?
Are Padma Awards losing sheen?
Are Padma Awards losing sheen?
Divide in the Saffron Brigade?
Divide in the Saffron Brigade?
26/11: An Indian among terrorist handlers?
26/11: An Indian among terrorist handlers?
Pak: No guarantees against 26/11 sequels
Pak: No guarantees against 26/11 sequels
Krishna: Why are only Indians attacked?
Krishna: Why are only Indians attacked?
Books versus Internet
Books versus Internet
I'm not anti-media: Big B
I'm not anti-media: Big B
No Marathi, no taxi on Buck Stops Here
No Marathi, no taxi on Buck Stops Here
Taking RTI too far?
Taking RTI too far?
Has cricket become too political?
Has cricket become too political?
All safe 'at Home'?
All safe 'at Home'?
The Amar saga
The Amar saga
The Buck Stops Here with Barkha Dutt
The Buck Stops Here with Barkha Dutt
Ruchika's case: A father's fight for justice
Ruchika's case: A father's fight for justice
New visa rules: Security or paranoia?
New visa rules: Security or paranoia?
Telangana on hold?
Telangana on hold?
Can't believe sweeper's statement: Kavita Karkare
Can't believe sweeper's statement: Kavita Karkare
Ruchika's story: Driven to death?
Ruchika's story: Driven to death?
Ruchika's story: Is the law too kind?
Ruchika's story: Is the law too kind?
Voting: Right or duty?
Voting: Right or duty?
The Blair years: 10 Downing and after
The Blair years: 10 Downing and after
The euthanasia debate
The euthanasia debate
Shopian mess: Playing politics with truth?
Shopian mess: Playing politics with truth?
Telangana crisis: Will it divide Congress?
Telangana crisis: Will it divide Congress?
Will Dinakaran resign?
Will Dinakaran resign?
David Headley: Truth and lies
David Headley: Truth and lies
Why govt agreed to Telangana statehood?
Why govt agreed to Telangana statehood?
Climate change: India's offer at Copenhagen
Climate change: India's offer at Copenhagen
'My love should not be tested in terms of religion'
'My love should not be tested in terms of religion'
Delhi govt vs Delhi police
Delhi govt vs Delhi police
Mediating with Deoband
Mediating with Deoband
Is Mamata the future of West Bengal?
Is Mamata the future of West Bengal?
Manu Sharma cuts short his parole
Manu Sharma cuts short his parole
Babbar wins on Mulayam's turf
Babbar wins on Mulayam's turf
Marathi Pride or Goonda 'Raj'?
Marathi Pride or Goonda 'Raj'?
Unlikely hero: Om Puri
Unlikely hero: Om Puri
Karnataka: Reddys not ready?
Karnataka: Reddys not ready?
Katrina's love affair with India
Katrina's love affair with India
Is the judiciary becoming more accountable and transparent?
Is the judiciary becoming more accountable and transparent?
Should politicians confront religious dogma more strongly?
Should politicians confront religious dogma more strongly?
Is it time to change industrialization policies in India's tribal regions?
Is it time to change industrialization policies in India's tribal regions?
Should Kiran Bedi be appointed as the new RTI boss?
Should Kiran Bedi be appointed as the new RTI boss?
Has the battle against Maoist violence become a proxy political war?
Has the battle against Maoist violence become a proxy political war?
The Bachchan Blockbuster
The Bachchan Blockbuster
Kashmir issue: Time to revive dialogue process with Pakistan?
Kashmir issue: Time to revive dialogue process with Pakistan?
Anti-Naxal offensive: Caught in the Mamata-CPM crossfire?
Anti-Naxal offensive: Caught in the Mamata-CPM crossfire?
Should sympathy for Maoists end?
Should sympathy for Maoists end?
Can Congress dump Raja?
Can Congress dump Raja?
Games before the Games
Games before the Games
Chidambaram's fresh appeal to Naxals
Chidambaram's fresh appeal to Naxals
Are Kashmiri Muslims treated unfairly?
Are Kashmiri Muslims treated unfairly?
Is Hindu extremism becoming a security threat?
Is Hindu extremism becoming a security threat?
Kalmadi-Hooper row: Wrestling of egos?
Kalmadi-Hooper row: Wrestling of egos?
India still an exotic tale for the West?
India still an exotic tale for the West?
Mittal's call for transparency
Mittal's call for transparency
Shiv Sena-BJP upbeat?
Shiv Sena-BJP upbeat?
Disappointed with Chinese stand: Krishna
Disappointed with Chinese stand: Krishna
Maharashtra polls: Do Cong-NCP need Raj Thackeray?
Maharashtra polls: Do Cong-NCP need Raj Thackeray?
Is the Ambani sibling rivalry a matter of public concern?
Is the Ambani sibling rivalry a matter of public concern?
Albania wants Mother Teresa back?
Albania wants Mother Teresa back?
Why do Indians do better abroad?
Why do Indians do better abroad?
Is it time for India's intelligence agencies to declassify history?
Is it time for India's intelligence agencies to declassify history?
Is poverty the root cause for Naxal violence?
Is poverty the root cause for Naxal violence?
Will Supreme Court be the undoing of Mayawati?
Will Supreme Court be the undoing of Mayawati?
Is it time to end intellectual sympathy for Naxals?
Is it time to end intellectual sympathy for Naxals?
Uddhav Thackeray unplugged
Uddhav Thackeray unplugged
This is Rahul Gandhi's self-discovery: Shahid Siddiqui
This is Rahul Gandhi's self-discovery: Shahid Siddiqui
My acting came of age because of Konkana: Ranbir
My acting came of age because of Konkana: Ranbir
Vilasrao Deshmukh to return to state politics?
Vilasrao Deshmukh to return to state politics?
India to Dalai Lama: Preach but not politics
India to Dalai Lama: Preach but not politics
Do women always face the brunt of tradition?
Do women always face the brunt of tradition?
Is the government to blame for the Air India crisis?
Is the government to blame for the Air India crisis?
The Q files: Is it time to bury the Bofors controversy?
The Q files: Is it time to bury the Bofors controversy?
Only unionised pilots to get incentives: Praful
Only unionised pilots to get incentives: Praful
What scares Akshay Kumar?
What scares Akshay Kumar?
Brand IIT in danger
Brand IIT in danger
Is Naxalism still romanticised?
Is Naxalism still romanticised?
All Episodes
Indian icon under attack
Delhi govt vs Delhi police
The Bengal tigeress
Marathi pride or Goonda 'Raj'?
Judges exit Reliance case
The Deoband debate
From Cop to Watchdog?
The Kashmir peace initiative
Mamata and the Naxal card
Fighting the ideological war
Battle for Buddhi's release
Talking with the Maoists
Saffron terror: Myth or reality
Terror-occupied Pakistan
Secular politics: A Myth?
Brothers in Arms
The Taliban threat
Justifying terror
Mayawati vs The State of Law
The Dalit battleground
Trapped by tradition
National Carrier, National Mess
Brand IIT in danger
Searching for a revolution
Rajiv's assassin wants freedom
Is Lalu still a force to reckon with?
Twitter generation and rules of politics
Blind justice?
Alarmed at Pakistan, cautious with China
The Modi Phenomenon
Sibal, the Reformer
Politicians and Statues
Faking Justice
The mystery of the missing Chief Minister
Bribery or Theatre?
BJP: The crisis within
Pakistan Under Siege
Clear mandate, unclear portfolios
BJP: The Crisis Within
Mamata's Left Hook
Mayawati: From Phenomenon to Politician
The Rahul Effect
Is the Left moving Centre?
Qasab: Justice delayed?
All Options Open
The Evolution of Rahul
Nitish's Waiting Game
Phase 3: Make or break?
The March of the Taliban
The 'Q' Factor
Halfway Mark: Who has an edge?
Election '09: What are the non-issues?
The Muslim Vote
Parting with ideology?
India votes: Round One
Qasab's lawyer sacked
Manmohan: Technocrat to Neta?
America's Afghan-Pak policy
If you were in his shoes...
Will Nitish do a Naveen on BJP?
Varun vs Tytler
Law vs Tradition
No Netagiri for Munnabhai
Varun: The Making of a Martyr
PMK deserts UPA
Back to hardline roots?
UPA, a house of cards?
Gandhi vs Gandhi
Unlikely Politician
Communal Politics
Tremors within BJP
ADVERTISEMENT
Send us your thoughts
* Name
* E-mail
* City
* Your Comments
Read surfer comments
In the News
Jagdish Tytler, Sajjan Kumar not to contest LS elections
NDTV Correspondent
Thursday, April 09, 2009
Congress leaders Jagdish Tytler and Sajjan Kumar are out of the poll race. The decision has been taken by their party. Both have been at the centre of the controversy relating to the November 1984 anti-Sikh riots.
NDTV I will react after court judgement: Tytler
NDTV PM seeks explanation on Tytler from CBI
 
Surfers Say
Posted by Rahul on Thursday, April 09, 2009 , Pune
No one is discussing how to improve and speed up the judiciary so that the Judgments are really given and that to in time. one thing i want to suggest that if lower Courts have convicted a person then he should not be allowed to contest though the person has gone in appeal but if he is not convicted then he be allowed to contest though the state has filed an appeal. of course i really don't say the Judiciary is independent as it appears in academic or in constitution which is the other big problem.
Posted by Krishna on Thursday, April 09, 2009 , Chennai
Credibility builds gradually - it takes effort and time to gain and sustain it. Iit dents very quicky when interests and safety of the people are compromized. It snaps instantaneously when 'party' is put before the nation!

All political parties should have learnt their lessons from history - but alas they show no signs of that!

Narrow political gains, and not nation building, seems to be the goal for all parties. When will INDIA and Indians recognize this? When will we learn to distinguish real leaders from the opportunists?
Posted by Vijay on Thursday, April 09, 2009 , Port Blair
What happened in 1984 was shame and should be taken as ill-effects of the civilized society. But what is happening now is more dangerous - all political parties trying to take maximum mileage out off the incident to divert the attention of the common man. Its very SAD
Posted by Anil Kohli on Thursday, April 09, 2009 , Mumbai
The political Russian Roulette has gone horribly wrong for Congress.

The ramification are long term, regardless of what the spokes persons of the Congress party may say.

Is this the proverbial last straw on the camels back?
Posted by Mayoor Bhatia on Thursday, April 09, 2009 , Mumbai
The Congress has a lot to gain and nothing to lose if they decide to drop Tytler from their list of candidates. His continuance in the fray would only put the party on the defensive, and give a readymade issue on the platter for their opponents to capitalize on.
Posted by Somasekhar V K on Thursday, April 09, 2009 , Bengaluru
I have been closely following the `Sikh riot issue of 1984’ and how Jagadish Tytler put up his defence today through his Press Meet. As a citizen of this country I feel outraged by the sheer fact that even though the genocide killed 3000 people which indeed a fact, innocent Sikhs were killed and their property shattered, we as a Nation haven’t been able to find out the truth and punish the real victims.

Leaving aside the Politicians who do want to survive on such episodes, as a journalist, I feel terribly slighted that we have not been able to give our support and put forth the evidence truly in the correct perspective. Somewhere, there seems to be a flaw and a charge that we are getting more accustomed to getting into the herd mentality and trying to stereo type our views, comments and also news. Here are some questions:

Jarnail Singh’s anguish was that, even after 25 yrs the Sikh Community had not got justice? He did not want politicization of the issue.

? Valid point, why are we repeatedly concentrating on the attack on the home Minister and not revealing the true facts to the public? How many commissions were set up, what does the FIR say (Tytler clearly says that not a singe constable visited him!?? Till date that a Commissioner of Police has given him a clean chit? )

? Tytler seems to be pointing a finger at Former Prime Minister-Atal Behari Vajpayee’s office and also some RSS people in this episode repeatedly! What’s the truth? Why are we sidestepping this issue? Strange that except him nobody else in the Congress is also stating this! What a contradiction? Why don’t we bring up the RSS chief or their spokesperson to respond to this? BJP is going hammer and tongs on this issue, why don’t we brace them up with these questions and get a response?

? Badal says that it is not just a candidature but arrests of the culprits. Fine, who are they? Where is the snag? He should be put questions that Tytler is saying Viz: Not a single FIR or charge sheet or any case against him? Infact the lawyers who represent the victims should also be asked these questions because they are not politicians?!!

I am distressed to see the same stress by all the electronic media about, Whether Tytler gets the ticket or not? Rather than the true story of what really matters.

Take for instance the Union Carbide tragedy in Bhopal, the victims never got justice and the Company got away.

Need we say more about genocides in India and how justice is slow, thereby people loose faith in Judiciary. We really need to ponder?
Posted by Prakash Sharma on Thursday, April 09, 2009 , Kolkata
India is supposed to be a secular country. All Non BJP parties confer themselves as secular. But a large section of the population, including me, believes that though India is a secular state the concept of secularism doesnot exist in Indian politics. Only concept which work is that of vote bank politics and nobody is bothered about anybodies communal sentiments
Posted by A.P. Dutta on Thursday, April 09, 2009 , London
It is clear that all thies parties have no moral value. They are trying all sort of degraded politics . By hook or crook they want to be in power wharever may be the qualition of the central govt. They do not care for the people.
Posted by Hariprasad on Thursday, April 09, 2009 , Bangalore
The very fact that the process and to make a decision on a riot incidence has taken 25 years shows the commitment it has (not) shown.

In public meetings they may go on condemning the attack but practically no justice has been delivered to proove that they work hard for justice.
Posted by Sushil on Thursday, April 09, 2009 , UAE
Why only 84 riots we are talking about? what happened to babri demolition culprits? what happened to criminals of Godra riots? We should not forget the siks were silent when they wanted to have seperate nation. How many innocent people have been killed by pro Kalistan terrorist. Nobody is talking about that. Who stopped kalistan terrorist? Its Indira ghandhi who has to pay her life to keep India intact. If not for Indira Ghandhi we would have had now another neighbouring country called KHALISTAN.