- Not just Maharashtra but India saw how rules and tradition were violated to win the trust vote
- Their promise to run a clean government have been exposed by the way Constitution violations were committed
- Their hypocrisy has been exposed
- It's not in the interest of democracy to strangle these traditional processes
- When Opposition asked for a count of votes why was a voice vote allowed? Why did the Speaker turn down the Sena's demand for a division of votes?
- Why could the government not prove their claims of a majority on the floor of the House?
- Was it to cover up the fact that the they had the support of a corrupt party the reason behind this?
- The government must answer these questions. Maharashtra wants these answers.
- Even if we were late in our demand to seek a vote count, the government should have allowed it as they were so confident of proving their majority
- The government has failed to prove their majority and must answer
- Those who crush the Constitution to win the vote of confidence, can they win the the people's trust?
- They have lost the moral right to govern on day 1 itself.
- Those who want to stay in power by corrupt practices should no longer assure good governance
- Through the scam of a voice vote they may have proved their majority but it is not a majority, nor we or law-abiding citizens will accept this
- There is no repentance for the sin of betraying the people's confidence
- You may have got a six month extension but have lost the people's trust
Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis' minority BJP government has won a confidence motion in the Maharashtra Assembly through a voice vote, amid much drama and controversy.
Five Congress legislators from Maharashtra have been suspended for allegedly manhandling and injuring Governor C Vidyasagar Rao at the assembly premises on Wednesday evening. Congress and Shiv Sena MLAs were protesting against the controversial confidence motion that Devendra Fadnavis' minority BJP government had won by voice vote hours ago.
'Have asked Governor to decide on legitimacy of government': Mr Chavan
'Did try blocking Governor's passage, but no intent to insult': Mr Chavan
'Imagine Maharashtra being ruled by a minority government': Mr Chavan
'If Congress MLA was wrong, I will be the first to regret': Mr Chavan
5 Congress lawmakers suspended from the Maharashtra Assembly for reportedly manhandling and injuring Governor C Vidyasagar Rao.
My Best Wishes to Shri Eknath Shinde for his tenure as the Leader of Opposition.We look forward for support for the development of Our State
- Devendra Fadnavis (@Dev_Fadnavis) November 12, 2014
I thank all Members of Assembly for the trust shown upon us.I assure that each step by Our Govt will be in the interest of ppl ofMaharashtra
- Devendra Fadnavis (@Dev_Fadnavis) November 12, 2014
- The government has betrayed the trust of the people of Maharashtra
- On the first day, they didn't act according to procedure.
- We will speak to NCP on whether we can work on getting a motion against the Speaker
- Maybe the NCP will not come with us - I know what goes on inside is different - we will also talk to the Congress
- The BJP has tainted the assembly, the people of Maharashtra will not forgive them
Proper procedure not followed in passing confidence motion by voice vote: Maharashtra Congress chief Manikrao Thakre.
- Press Trust of India (@PTI_News) November 12, 2014
- We strongly condemn the decision by the Speaker to not hold another vote
- There should be another confidence vote in Maharashtra, the BJP should prove its majority
- This is a black-day for democracy in Maharashtra -
- This is an illegitimate government
- The government must bring the confidence motion again; people should know whether this is a minority government or whether they enjoy majority
- Our demand of a division was turned down by the speaker, all Congress lawmakers will go to the governor now .
- We will not let the Assembly function.
Devendra Fadnavis' minority BJP government has won a confidence motion in the Maharashtra Assembly through a voice vote and will remain in power.
The Shiv Sena's legislators shouted the loudest nays, voting against the BJP. Sharad Pawar's NCP remained silent to abstain from the vote.
Ahead of the trust vote, a senior Shiv Sena leader had said his party would not vote in favour of the BJP's minority government. And soon after, Sharad Pawar's Nationalist Congress Party reiterated that its offer of support to the BJP to ensure a stable government stands.
The win means that the government of Mr Fadnavis, 44, sworn in 13 days ago is safe for now. This morning he had also crossed another hurdle, with the BJP winning the Speaker's post unopposed, after the Shiv Sena and the Congress withdrew their candidates.
- Devendra Fadnavis wins trust vote in Maharashtra Assembly
- There was no division - the Fadnavis-government won on a voice vote.
Ahead of the BJP government's trust vote in Maharashtra Assembly today, the Shiv Sena has warned its former ally that it will be disrespecting people's mandate if it takes support of the NCP which "nibbled the state coffers like a mouse".
Senior BJP legislator Haribhau Bagde was today unanimously elected as the Speaker of the Maharashtra Assembly after Shiv Sena and Congress withdrew their candidates.
Ahead of the BJP government's trust vote in Maharashtra Assembly today, the Shiv Sena has warned its former ally that it will be disrespecting people's mandate if it takes support of the NCP which "nibbled the state coffers like a mouse".
On a big day in the Maharashtra Assembly, the minority BJP government has crossed a first hurdle, getting the Speaker's post unchallenged after the Shiv Sena and the Congress withdrew their candidates. Now, Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis of the BJP must win the floor test for his party to remain in power.
- We met the Governor and asked permission to form the government.
- He has invited us to form the government and the swearing-in ceremony is on October 31.
- We have to prove our majority in 15 days.
Mumbai : BJP leaders meet Maharashtra Governor, stake claim to form Government pic.twitter.com/DEOcTVLrkj
- ANI (@ANI_news) October 28, 2014
The 44-year-old four-term legislator from Nagpur will be the BJP's first Maharashtra chief minister.
- Will follow the same path followed by PM Modi - of inclusiveness, development, transparency.
- Thankful to all my leaders and members of Legislative Party.
- Eknath Khadse ji proposed my name and it was affirmed by everyone. I want to thank everyone for their support.
- I thank everyone for choosing me as the legislative party head.
- There are many people in Maharashtra BJP who are capable of taking this responsibility and yet they chose me, I thank them.
- I thank PM Narendra Modi and (BJP President) Amit shah.
- We will decide what are the last minute deliberations,major decisions to be taken,there has to be consensus,have to stake claims
- There will be a meeting of the MLAs. Rajnath Singh will be there as observer, leader of Legislative party will be decided
Devendra Fadnavis, proponent of cool during political heat, may have to reach deep into his reserves of calm.
Top BJP leaders say that the party is comfortable with its government being in a minority to start with.
Home Minister and senior BJP leader Rajnath Singh will act as observer at the 4 pm meeting in Mumbai.
Devendra Fadnavis, the BJP's 44-year-old state chief is expected to be chosen as Maharashtra's next chief minister at a meeting of the party's newly-elected legislators today.
Pritam Munde, the younger daughter of the late BJP leader Gopinath Munde, scripted history on Sunday with a record victory margin of around 7 lakh votes in the Lok Sabha by-elections from her father's home turf Beed.
Speaking exclusively to NDTV, she said:
- People sympathetic to us to an extent but they believe we can take our father's legacy forward
Following are the highlights of his interview:
- I lead the campaign in Maharashtra, therefore the entire responsibility of poor performance in the state lies with me
- We believe our developmental record would speak for itself; NCP deserted us minutes before the final date of filing
- We had to search for candidates and logistics of it
- Never before a PM has campaigned so aggressively
- It also underlines the fact that there was no Modi wave, he had to use all the state machinery to create the aura of Modi phenomenon
- There was 15 years of Congress rule, charges of corruption against government, tried to correct the situation but couldn't reach ultimate result
I have not given any proposal to anyone but if anyone comes with a proposal we can think of it. If the BJP doesn't come with a proposal, then what can I do about it?
My gratitude to the people of Maharashtra. We are committed to Maharashtra's progress & creating a Maharashtra the world will be proud of.
- Narendra Modi (@narendramodi) October 19, 2014
Thanks to the people of Haryana for giving us the opportunity to fulfil their dreams & to take Haryana's development journey to new heights.
- Narendra Modi (@narendramodi) October 19, 2014
The Congress Party accepts the election verdict delivered by the people of Maharashtra and Haryana with humility and resolves to play a constructive and vigilant role.
We accept the verdict of people. People have voted for change, after 15 years of our government in Maharashtra and 10 years in Haryana. I congratulate the BJP on their success. The Congress Party will work hard on the ground to once again earn the confidence of the people.
- In both Haryana and Maharashtra, BJP has recorded its biggest ever victory.
- We're going to form the government in both states and the Congress has been pushed to the third spot.
- Congress will not even get Leader of Opposition status in both the states.
- I thank the people of both the states and we will live up to their expectations.
- It is a victory of the people of both the states and of thousands of BJP workers.
- It has been proved beyond doubt that people in India consider Narendra Modi their undisputed leader.
- We have moved two steps ahead in making India 'Congress-mukt'.
- Few people criticized Modi wave. Now it has become clear that the wave has turned into a Tsunami.
- We didn't break the alliance with Shiv Sena.
- The government begins with the chief minister.
- (In Maharashtra) there will be a BJP government and a BJP chief minister.
- NCP has offered to extend outside support. An alliance would mean being in the government.
- We have not spoken to anyone yet. We have a parliamentary board meeting in the evening where we'll decide.
- We will form the government and it will run well. But we are now in the mood to celebrate, so no one has given it (alliances) serious thought yet.
All options are open: Devendra Fadnavis on Govt formation in Maharashtra pic.twitter.com/VrLkQ1SM7m
- ANI (@ANI_news) October 19, 2014
BJP-NCP? @praful_patel says can offer outside support. @Dev_Fadnavis tells me: we will look into it." Doesn't reject it. What's cooking?
- Tejas Mehta (@tejasndtv) October 19, 2014
As per latest trends:
BJP: 119
Shiv Sena: 59
Congress: 44
NCP: 43
BJP President Amit Shah arrives at BJP Headquarters in Delhi pic.twitter.com/vLpo706xei
- ANI (@ANI_news) October 19, 2014
We will introspect, will play the role of constructive opposition: Prithviraj Chavan pic.twitter.com/GEnu4pfsCU
- ANI (@ANI_news) October 19, 2014
We were expecting more,but we respect Public's mandate, we congratulate new Govt to be formed: Abhay Chautala,INLD pic.twitter.com/LeDLnfpsIp
- ANI (@ANI_news) October 19, 2014
30 mins to go for the #Contest to close. Tweet your answers using #NDTVResults to win an Android One phone.T&C apply: http://t.co/lLcUeASfdh
- NDTV (@ndtv) October 19, 2014
(Picture courtesy: Press Trust of India)
In Maharashtra, late BJP leader Gopinath Munde's daughter Pankaja won from Parli. Shiv Sena's Ajinkya Patil, son of D Y Patil, lost to Prithiviraj Chavan in Karad South
over 23,000 votes: Press Trust of India
BJP and Shiv Sena are the top two, if Uddhav ji gets a proposal from BJP it shall be discussed: Anil Desai, Shiv Sena pic.twitter.com/VzolMP0Xqd
- ANI (@ANI_news) October 19, 2014
Last question is out. Tweet your answers using #NDTVResults to win an Android One phone. The #Contest will close soon.
- NDTV (@ndtv) October 19, 2014
I respect public mandate, accept this defeat: BS Hooda pic.twitter.com/gjJDRXq1um
- ANI (@ANI_news) October 19, 2014
In #Haryana, Congress's Savitri Jindal loses from Hisar. #NDTVResults http://t.co/ZCKYEbrTCl
- NDTV (@ndtv) October 19, 2014
Prithviraj Chavan's supporters celebrate his victory from Karad (Maharashtra) pic.twitter.com/FvCWYaCGEC
- ANI (@ANI_news) October 19, 2014
#Contest Q9:How many seats does the Haryana Legislative Assembly have?Answer now with #NDTVResults to win an Android One phone.Coming up Q10
- NDTV (@ndtv) October 19, 2014
Sources say the BJP is not keen on coalition talks with Sena.
Celebrations are o in full swing outside the BJP Mumbai headquarters
People have voted for good governance,they have rejected Cong, it's a positive mandate: I&B Min Prakash Javadekar pic.twitter.com/1sXRouaRCw
- ANI (@ANI_news) October 19, 2014
These are just early trends, hopeful of getting above 50 seats, but we still are not satisfied: Manikrao Thakre, Cong pic.twitter.com/XWH8hLtYc4
- ANI (@ANI_news) October 19, 2014
Early trends have made it clear that results are not on the lines we expected:Rajeev Shukla, Cong pic.twitter.com/uBCemiuHkF
- ANI (@ANI_news) October 19, 2014
While BJP leads in 47 seats, INLD is gaining in 19 and Congress in 13.
At BJP HQ Mumbai, Om Mathur, state in charge and Vinod Tawde, Mumbai BJP President. #ndtvresults pic.twitter.com/0BjApbnbHq
- Sreenivasan Jain (@SreenivasanJain) October 19, 2014
BJP ahead in 117, Shiv Sena in 58, Congress 46 and NCP 45
Q6 is out. Coming up #Contest Q7. Tweet your answers using #NDTVResults to win an Android One phone.T&C apply: http://t.co/lLcUeASfdh
- NDTV (@ndtv) October 19, 2014
In Nagpur Devendra Fadnavis' wife Amruta & mother Sarita glued to the TV. She says: Devendra ready to be CM pic.twitter.com/yW4ZeADOhp
- Tejas Mehta (@tejasndtv) October 19, 2014
#Maharashtra leads at 9:40 am (282/288): BJP ahead in 116 seats, Shiv Sena in 59. #NDTVResults http://t.co/yIGu65Cg3w #NDTVResults
- NDTV (@ndtv) October 19, 2014
Haryana leads at 9:40 am (87/90): BJP leads in 47, INLD+ leads in 20, Congress in 15. http://t.co/3LiKCz9CkH #NDTVResults
- NDTV (@ndtv) October 19, 2014
#Contest Q6: In which city is the Winter session of the Maharashtra legislature held? Answer now with #NDTVResults to win.Coming up Q7.
- NDTV (@ndtv) October 19, 2014
This is all one man show,they (BJP) had no leader in Maharashtra, let's wait and see final results: Majid Memon, NCP pic.twitter.com/rIO0zkleQf
- ANI (@ANI_news) October 19, 2014
BJP - 44
INLD - 17
Congress - 15
The MLA hostel where Devendra Fadnavis stays when in Mumbai. Trademark simplicity. pic.twitter.com/Qu8ml8Mhj1
- Sreenivasan Jain (@SreenivasanJain) October 19, 2014
Yes, BJP is getting more seats as per trends, but Shiv Sena is also performing well: Sanjay Raut, Shiv Sena pic.twitter.com/TfUDShLWyH
- ANI (@ANI_news) October 19, 2014
Q5 is out. Coming up #Contest Q6. Tweet your answers using #NDTVResults to win an Android One phone.T&C apply: http://t.co/lLcUeASfdh
- NDTV (@ndtv) October 19, 2014
You can always tell when the mood is a bit down and out. Handful of supporters at #hooda home in #rohtak pic.twitter.com/koXavTvLNi
- sunetra choudhury (@sunetrac) October 19, 2014
Assembly Elections, early trends, Celebrations outside BJP Headquarters in Delhi pic.twitter.com/frWZdYFYYi
- ANI (@ANI_news) October 19, 2014
Congress's Randeep Singh Surjewala trails in Kaithal but Bhupinder Singh Hooda leads in Garhi-Sampla Kiloi.
This is what the BJP office in Mumbai looks like right now
BJP - 48
Shiv Sena - 23
Congress - 16
NCP - 13
Shiv Sena leads in Thane, Maharashtra.
Counting has begun. Happy to be on a show without the tension of getting forecast right or party's performance.
- Yogendra Yadav (@AapYogendra) October 19, 2014
Maharashtra Assembly Election, Counting begins in Nagpur pic.twitter.com/nGImITmvXA
- ANI (@ANI_news) October 19, 2014
Haryana Assembly Election, EVMs being opened, counting begins in Panchkula pic.twitter.com/S8YwQK00BU
- ANI (@ANI_news) October 19, 2014