New Delhi: The Chief Justice of India has rejected the government's move to put in place a committee of retired judges to evaluate the applications of candidates before forwarding them to the collegium to decide whether to recommend their names for elevation or appointment as judges.
Chief Justice of India TS Thakur expressed his reservations over the clause in the revised draft memorandum of procedure (MoP) when External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj, who headed the Group of Ministers which drafted the MoP, and Law Minister DV Sadananda Gowda met him at his residence on Wednesday evening.
Parliament had enacted the National Judicial Appointments Commission Act to do away with the over two-decade old collegium system where judges appoint judges. The law was struck down by the Supreme Court on October 16 last year.
A Supreme Court bench, while deciding on ways to make the collegium system more transparent, had asked the Centre to redraft the MoP in consultation with the states.
The MoP is a document which guides the appointment of judges to the Supreme Court and the 24 high courts. At present, there are two MoPs -- one for the Supreme Court and the other for the High Courts.
The government had sent the MoP to the SC collegium in March. The CJI had returned the document in May raising objections to the various clauses.
Wednesday's meeting was aimed at narrowing down the differences between the executive and the judiciary on MoP.
At the meeting, Justice Thakur said the committee of retired judges to evaluate the applications by candidates for appointment was unacceptable, highly placed source said.
The government wanted the proposed committee to evaluate the experience of aspirants in detail before making recommendations to the collegium for taking a final call.
One committee was proposed at the Supreme Court level and 24 others for each of the high courts.
While the government and the collegium were on the same page on having secretariats in high courts to process judicial appointments, the judiciary had earlier opposed defining the role of the proposed secretariat.
At the meeting, however, there was an agreement on defining the role and functions of the secretariat.
Chief Justice of India TS Thakur expressed his reservations over the clause in the revised draft memorandum of procedure (MoP) when External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj, who headed the Group of Ministers which drafted the MoP, and Law Minister DV Sadananda Gowda met him at his residence on Wednesday evening.
Parliament had enacted the National Judicial Appointments Commission Act to do away with the over two-decade old collegium system where judges appoint judges. The law was struck down by the Supreme Court on October 16 last year.
The MoP is a document which guides the appointment of judges to the Supreme Court and the 24 high courts. At present, there are two MoPs -- one for the Supreme Court and the other for the High Courts.
Advertisement
Wednesday's meeting was aimed at narrowing down the differences between the executive and the judiciary on MoP.
Advertisement
The government wanted the proposed committee to evaluate the experience of aspirants in detail before making recommendations to the collegium for taking a final call.
Advertisement
While the government and the collegium were on the same page on having secretariats in high courts to process judicial appointments, the judiciary had earlier opposed defining the role of the proposed secretariat.
Advertisement
COMMENTS
Advertisement
Husband-Wife Fight Solved By Lok Adalat Bench Of Chief Justice, Kapil Sibal Chief Justice DY Chandrachud Says Marked "Shift" In Approach Towards Disability "Call Security": Chief Justice Blasts Lawyer, He Quotes Bible In Reply Vandalism At Kolkata Hospital Where Doctor Was Raped, Tear Gas Fired 150 mg Semen In Kolkata Doctor's Body, Suspect Gang-Rape: Parents To Court "Want To Ask Congress...": Mamata Banerjee Snaps At Ally In Rape-Murder Case Professor 'Digitally Arrested' For 12 Days By Scammers, Loses Rs 12 Lakh Independence Day 2024 Live Updates: PM Modi To Address Nation From Red Fort PM Modi To Address Nation From Red Fort On 78th Independence Day Today Track Latest News Live on NDTV.com and get news updates from India and around the world.