This Article is From Feb 17, 2022

Hijab Row Highlights: "Banning Hijab Amounts To Banning Quran": Petitioners To High Court

In an attempt to calm tensions, Karnataka's state government temporarily closed schools last week but have been opening gradually over the last two days.

Advertisement
India News

In an attempt to calm tensions, Karnataka's state government temporarily closed schools last week

The Karnataka High Court today adjourned hearing in petitions filed by Muslim girls studying in government pre-university colleges in Udupi against the government ban on Hijabs in classrooms. The court will resume hearing the pleas on Friday, after state advocate general Prabhuling Navadgi sought time to respond to the petitions.

The arguments in the case come amid simmering tension in Karnataka where late last year, students were prevented from wearing the Muslim headscarf, sparking protests and counter demonstrations involving saffron scarves that have since spread to other states.

In an attempt to calm tensions, Karnataka's state government temporarily closed schools last week but have been opening gradually over the last two days. The Karnataka High Court has imposed a temporary ban on the wearing of all religious symbols in schools while it considers the headscarf ban.

Here are the Highlights on the Hijab Row:

Feb 17, 2022 18:10 (IST)
Congress Protest Seeking Minister's Resignation Mars Karnataka Assembly Proceedings

Protests by the Congress demanding sacking of Rural Development and Panchayat Raj Minister KS Eshwarappa and that he be charged for sedition, for his statement on the national flag, continued to rock the Assembly proceedings in Karnataka for the second consecutive day on Thursday.

While the Congress has decided to hold 'day-and-night' protests to take the issue to a "logical end", Mr Eshwarappa said he won't quit.

Mr Eshwarappa said there is no question of him resigning for any reason, and he is a patriot who had gone to jail during emergency.

"Let them protest, I won't budge," he said, and demanded that state Congress chief DK Shivakumar resign, accusing him and his party of 'misusing' the national flag for protests.
Feb 17, 2022 17:46 (IST)
Allow Hijab During Ramzan: Fresh Appeal In Karnataka High Court

A fresh petition has been filed in the Karnataka High Court seeking that hijab be allowed in educational institutions during on Fridays and the holy month of Ramzan.  Read Here
Feb 17, 2022 16:35 (IST)
Allow Students To Wear Hijab At Least On Fridays, Says Petitioner

Counsel Vinod Kulkarni, appearing on behalf of the Muslim girls requested the bench to allow students to wear Hijab to schools on Fridays. He said, "Friday is jumma. Please, for now, allow the students to wear the hijab on Fridays at least. This interim order is creating mass hysteria." 

Feb 17, 2022 16:21 (IST)
Hijab Row: High Court Asks Senior Advocate AM Dar To Withdraw His Current Petition
Feb 17, 2022 15:59 (IST)
Hijab Row: Karnataka High Court adjourns the hearing for Friday, 2.30 pm
Advertisement
Feb 17, 2022 15:38 (IST)
Hijab row limited to only 8 high schools and pre-university colleges in Karnataka: Government
 The hijab row persists only in eight high schools and pre-university colleges of the total 75,000, the Karnataka government said on Thursday, expressing confidence of resolving the issue.

The High Court, in its interim order pending consideration of all petitions related to the hijab row, last week restrained all the students from wearing saffron shawls, scarves, hijab and any religious flag within the classroom.

However, the controversy refuses to die down as some students remained adamant to be allowed to attend classes with 'Hijab' and 'Burqa' on Thursday as well.
Feb 17, 2022 15:28 (IST)
Dar : I will file affidavit. Because they are studying. We are regular students in Bangalore.

J Dixit : You should state which petitioner is studying in which college. This is an important matter. We have adopted the provisions of CPC. It requires all material particulars to be pleaded. You have not pleaded, which school you are studying, which school has prevented.
Feb 17, 2022 15:27 (IST)
Justice Dixit : Please read.

Dar : Please see...one sec

J Dixit : You are wasting precious time.

Dar :  I have said it.

J Dixit : Please read.
Feb 17, 2022 15:26 (IST)
Justice Dixit : This is not a PIL?

Dar : This is a petition filed by affected students.

J Dixit : Which institutions they are studying? Where have you stated the institution prevented?

Dar : I have given all details.
Feb 17, 2022 15:25 (IST)
Now Senior Adv AM Dar makes submissions.

"This GO is unconstitutional and cryptic in nature".

CJ : First let us understand your locus.

Dar : We are five girls, students studying in colleges, we are going to be affected. We are putting hijab.
Feb 17, 2022 15:25 (IST)
Dr Kulkarni : I am a devout Brahmin myself.... my submission is it may amount to the banning of Quran. My submission is that please pass an order today to allow wearing of hijab on Friday and ensuing Ramzan.

Dr Kulkarni again cites Lata Mangeshkar song "Kuch Pakar Kuch Khona hain".
Feb 17, 2022 15:21 (IST)
CJ : Can you show it where in Quran it is stated?

Kulkarni : Right now I cannot, but much has been said about it. Banning hijab tantamouts to banning Quran.
Feb 17, 2022 15:21 (IST)
Kulkarni refers to Lata Mangeshkar song "kuch Pakar kuch khona hai..."

Kulkarni says there are 5 duties for a Muslim.

CJ : You want them to be allowed hijab on Fridays? CJ: We will consider what you argue.
Feb 17, 2022 15:20 (IST)
CJ : In prayer A, you say students should wear stipulated uniform.  Prayer b you say allow to wear uniform with hijab.

Kulkarni : Hijab is part of the uniform my lords.
Feb 17, 2022 15:20 (IST)
CJ : Read your prayers. 

Kulkarni reads.

Chief Justice : You want a declaration that whatever uniform has prescribed they shall wear that uniform. Your prayers are contradictory.
Feb 17, 2022 15:19 (IST)
CJ  : What is your relief?

Kulkarni : Interim relief I am claiming is that pass an order to let Muslim girls sport Hijab at least on Friday, on Juma day, most auspices day for Muslims and the holy month of Ramzan, which is coming soon.
Feb 17, 2022 15:18 (IST)
Kulkarni : I have made all declarations as per the Rules.

Bench going through the papers.
Feb 17, 2022 15:18 (IST)
Now Dr Vinod Kulkarni makes submissions as party in person.

"This hijab issue is creating a hysteria and is affecting the mental health of Muslim girls. As per preamble of constitution, guarding health is duty of the state"

CJ : This PIL is also not as per HC rules.
Feb 17, 2022 15:18 (IST)
Bench dismisses the PIL.

Kotwal: I have filed many petitions and this is the first time my petition has been dismissed on grounds of maintainability.

Justice Dixit : New rules have been framed after your petitions may have been filed.
Feb 17, 2022 15:17 (IST)
CJ to Kotwal: Your petition is not as per the rules.

Kotwal : It is an important matter, let us not get into technicalities. Provide me 3-4 minutes.

Justice Dixit : Rule 14 is not technicality.

CJ : We will dismiss your petition with costs. You are testing our nerves.



Advertisement