The marriage between a Muslim man and a Hindu woman is not valid under Muslim personal law even if registered under the Special Marriage Act, the Madhya Pradesh High Court has said while denying police protection to an interfaith couple.
The Muslim law does not permit a Muslim man's marriage with a "fire-worshipper", Justice GS Ahluwalia said while hearing a petition by the couple seeking police protection.
Safee Khan and Sarika Sen told the court they wished to marry under the Special Marriage Act, which allows marriages irrespective of the faith or religion followed by the groom and the bride, but couldn't do so due to threats from their family. They sought security for their safe appearance before the marriage registrar and protection from any criminal charges (like kidnapping) filed by their families.
The couple also asserted they wouldn't convert and that their marriage under the Special Marriage Act would override restrictions under the personal law. Sarika will remain a Hindu and Safee a Muslim and won't interfere with each other's religious practices, they said.
The woman's family, who opposed their petition, alleged that she had eloped with family jewellery and cash, and that interfaith marriage would lead them to societal ostracism.
After hearing both sides and examining relevant precedents, the court said a marriage between a Muslim man and an idol-worshipping woman is considered irregular, though not void.
"As per Mahomedan law, the marriage of a Muslim boy with a girl who is an idolatress or a fire-worshipper is not a valid marriage. Even if the marriage is registered under the Special Marriage Act, the marriage would be no more a valid marriage and it would be an irregular (fasid) marriage," Justice Ahluwalia said.
The court also highlighted the difference between valid (sahih), void (batil), and irregular (fasid) marriages in Muslim law, referencing the Supreme Court's interpretation in Mohammed Salim vs Shamsudeen and other authoritative texts.
Finding no grounds for granting police protection or other reliefs to the couple, it dismissed the petition.
Featured Video Of The Day
Poll Rules Tweak Makes Electronic Records Harder To Get, Sparks Row
Supreme Court Alimony Order For Muslim Women "Against" Islamic Law: Muslim Law Board "How Is Code Uniform If A Community Is Exempted": Muslim Body On Civil Code Allahabad High Court Rejects Protection Request Of 8 Interfaith Couples Is Safe Car Enough? Volvo Crash That Killed CEO, Family Sparks Big Question "Nothing Short Of Nightmare": Woman Misses Life Event, Slams Air India Snack Food Epigamia Founder Rohan Mirchandani Dies Of Cardiac Arrest At 41 Watch: Pak Girl Selling Snacks Speaks Flawless English, Impresses Internet Key Challenges Gen Z Students Face Abroad And How to Overcome Them Rahul Gandhi's Family Lunch At Iconic Delhi Restaurant Track Latest News Live on NDTV.com and get news updates from India and around the world.