Man Refused Passport Renewal Over "Updated" Date Of Birth. Delhi High Court Says...

Every citizen has the legal right to hold a passport and authorities cannot refuse to renew it merely on apprehension that the earlier passport might have been misused, the Delhi High Court said.

The court, while dealing with a petition by an Indian seeking a change in the date of birth mentioned in his passport, said a denial of the travel document seriously impedes the rights of a citizen, and the authorities can refuse to renew a passport or cancel it only on grounds prescribed in law.

In the present case, the authorities refused to renew the petitioner's passport with the updated date of birth on the ground that the claim for correction did not seem to be genuine.

The counsel for the passport authority told the court that nearly 14 years have passed since the first passport was issued to the petitioner and that he might misuse the travel document if it is renewed or re-issued with a new date of birth.

Rejecting the objection, the court noted that authorities have not provided any basis for rejecting the petitioner's renewal application which was supplemented with validly-issued government documents.

"Every citizen has a legal right to hold a passport and the right can be taken away only in accordance with law. The authorities are bound to follow the procedure prescribed under law and can refuse to renew/cancel a passport only on grounds prescribed in law," said Justice Subramonium Prasad in a recent order.

"In the present case, the only reason that is being put forward by the Respondent is a mere possibility that the earlier passports which had been issued on the basis of Birth Certificates dated 11.02.2003 and 02.07.2007 could have been misused which can never be a valid ground for denial of issuing the passport," the court said.

It said although the passport authorities have the power to verify the veracity of the documents, they cannot hold that the authority issuing the date of birth certificates has not done their job properly when all the relevant documents have been given to show the correct date of birth.

The mistake done by the parents of the petitioner in giving the wrong date of birth cannot be held against the petitioner, it added.

Setting aside the order refusing the renewal of the passport, the court directed a fresh passport with the changed date of birth be issued to the petitioner in accordance with the government documents produced by him.