This Article is From Sep 15, 2014

Manmohan Singh Should've Taken a Stand: Former CAG Vinod Rai on 2G Scam

New Delhi: Former Comptroller and Auditor General Vinod Rai has alleged that ex-Prime Minister Manmohan Singh failed to check corruption duirng his tenure - most notably in 2G spectrum and coal blocks allocation. Mr Rai's estimates of massive losses in these scams had pushed the UPA government into a corner. In his soon-to-be-released book "Not Just an Accountant", Mr Rai has singled out Dr Singh for stinging criticism.

He speaks to NDTV's Barkha Dutt. Here are the highlights:

  • On 2G scam: Not aware of statements made by Mr Raja, but our audit reports are based on facts
  • Prime Minister said he will keep himself at an arm's length; you cannot do such thing in a parliamentary democracy
  • The PM should have taken a stand, he should have consulted 2G spectrum allocation with a Group of Ministers
  • Former minister Ashwani Kumar asked me if PM's name could be kept out of the audit report
  • Nothing to suggest PM was complicit in 2G scam, he looked away
  • (Congress MPs) Sanjay Nirupam and Sandeep Dikshit wanted me to keep the PM's name out of audit reports
  • 3-4 Congress MPs said they saw reason in my 2G report
  • Former telecom minister A Raja wrote to the Prime Minister about his course of action, so PM knew
  • Unfair to say PM acted as an agent of his party leadership
  • The presumptive figure of loss to government (Rs 1.76 lakh crore) figure was a red flag, an alarm
  • Wrote a dozen letters to PM on many issues, he didn't respond
  • CAG's office got tremendous support from the media and judiciary
  • My book is not to find fault with anyone
  • My book is about bringing transparency in government procedures
  • On aircraft purchase by Air India: In an August 2004 meeting, the government advised them to go and take a longer perspective
  • Air India is an expert professional body, that is why the CMD protested in that meeting
  • I am not targeting Praful Patel
  • The debt went up to six billion dollars
  • The process in government is that any proposal coming from a Public Sector organisation should be verified, but the ministry took it to the Finance Ministry, which then raised doubts on this proposal
  • 'This is a supply driven proposal' - these were the exact words of the Finance Ministry
  • The draft report had not come to the CAG at that time
  • I think it was a gross commercial miscalculation by Air India to buy extra aircraft
  • On coal block allocation: I found it a strange thing that the coal minister rejected PM's auction decision
  • The auditing procedures are very structured
  • There are very limited circulations of these reports
  • We were holding press conferences only to explain these reports to the media
  • I have come out with this now because the shackles of these don't apply to me
  • Politics is not my cup of tea
  • For the last 16 months, I have proved that it's not my cup of tea and I still believe the same
  • Everybody has all options open

.