Mumbai:
Former Maharashtra Chief Minister Ashok Chavan and 13 others have been slapped with a money laundering case by the Enforcement Directorate(ED) for their alleged involvement in the Adarsh housing scam.
"An ECIR (Enforcement Case Information Report) has been registered under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA) on March 5 against 14 persons. The 14 persons are the same who have been named as accused by CBI in their FIR," senior counsel RV Desai appearing for the ED told the Bombay High Court today.
A division bench of Justices SA Bobade and Mridula Bhatkar were hearing petitions filed by social activists Pravin Wategaonkar and Simpreet Singh, demanding that the ED register a case, and the High Court to supervise the investigations of CBI and ED.
"The accused persons got clearances to construct Adarsh illegally and obtained flats at a very low price compared to market value. The accused projected tainted property as untainted. Prima facie it constitutes offence under section 3 of PMLA," the ECIR states.
The High Court took the ED to task for the way it has dealt with the case.
"In December last year the court had asked ED to make a statement on applicability on provisions of PMLA. But even today the agency is not able to make a conclusive statement on PMLA," Justice Bobade said.
"You (ED) say investigation has been initiated with registration of ECIR. So you must be having some material before you at this stage. On the basis of that material you should be able to make statement on when you will register an FIR in the case and when you will arrest the accused persons," the bench said.
Mr Desai told the court that the agency needs to find out if the accused persons had procured flats in the Adarsh society through funds which were proceeds of crime.
"We are awaiting CBI to complete its investigation and submit its charge sheet. ED will then take a decision on registration of FIR and arrest of accused," Mr Desai said.
The CBI informed the court that it would complete its probe by June 15 and file its chargesheet thereafter. The court has adjourned the matter till June 18.
The ED had earlier issued summons to the members of the Society directing them to furnish information regarding purchase of flats in the 31-storey housing society in south Mumbai and the mode of payment.
Those arrested include the Society's secretary RC Thakur, retired brigadier MM Wanchoo, former Congress MLC Kanhaiyalal Gidwani and Pradeep Vyas, former Mumbai collector.
The CBI, which registered a case in January last year against 14 people, has so far arrested nine persons including IAS officers Jairaj Phatak and Ramanand Tiwari, retired Major generals AR Kumar and TK Kaul and PV Deshmukh, a former deputy secretary in the Urban department.
The remaining five accused are Chavan, former principal secretary to the chief minister Subhash Lala, retired Colonel0 TK Sinha, retired brigadier PK Rampal and retired deputy GOC R C Sharma.
The court has also directed the ED and the CBI to file their reply on an affidavit filed by one of the petitioners Pravin Wategaonkar alleging that Union Minister Vilasrao Deshmukh owns two proxy flats in Adarsh.
Mr Wategaonkar in his affidavit had sought CBI and ED to investigate against Deshmukh and union minister Sushil Kumar Shinde.
The court has directed the agencies to file their reply by June 18 on the allegations.
Meanwhile, another bench of the High Court admitted the petition filed by Ministry of Defence seeking demolition of the 31-storey plush building in south Mumbai on the ground that it poses a security threat to the defence installations near the building.
A division bench of Justices SJ Vazifdar and AR Joshi posted the petition for final hearing beyond summer vacation.
The interim order directing the government to not grant any permission to the society will continue till final disposal of the petition.
"An ECIR (Enforcement Case Information Report) has been registered under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA) on March 5 against 14 persons. The 14 persons are the same who have been named as accused by CBI in their FIR," senior counsel RV Desai appearing for the ED told the Bombay High Court today.
A division bench of Justices SA Bobade and Mridula Bhatkar were hearing petitions filed by social activists Pravin Wategaonkar and Simpreet Singh, demanding that the ED register a case, and the High Court to supervise the investigations of CBI and ED.
"The accused persons got clearances to construct Adarsh illegally and obtained flats at a very low price compared to market value. The accused projected tainted property as untainted. Prima facie it constitutes offence under section 3 of PMLA," the ECIR states.
The High Court took the ED to task for the way it has dealt with the case.
"In December last year the court had asked ED to make a statement on applicability on provisions of PMLA. But even today the agency is not able to make a conclusive statement on PMLA," Justice Bobade said.
"You (ED) say investigation has been initiated with registration of ECIR. So you must be having some material before you at this stage. On the basis of that material you should be able to make statement on when you will register an FIR in the case and when you will arrest the accused persons," the bench said.
Mr Desai told the court that the agency needs to find out if the accused persons had procured flats in the Adarsh society through funds which were proceeds of crime.
"We are awaiting CBI to complete its investigation and submit its charge sheet. ED will then take a decision on registration of FIR and arrest of accused," Mr Desai said.
The CBI informed the court that it would complete its probe by June 15 and file its chargesheet thereafter. The court has adjourned the matter till June 18.
The ED had earlier issued summons to the members of the Society directing them to furnish information regarding purchase of flats in the 31-storey housing society in south Mumbai and the mode of payment.
Those arrested include the Society's secretary RC Thakur, retired brigadier MM Wanchoo, former Congress MLC Kanhaiyalal Gidwani and Pradeep Vyas, former Mumbai collector.
The CBI, which registered a case in January last year against 14 people, has so far arrested nine persons including IAS officers Jairaj Phatak and Ramanand Tiwari, retired Major generals AR Kumar and TK Kaul and PV Deshmukh, a former deputy secretary in the Urban department.
The remaining five accused are Chavan, former principal secretary to the chief minister Subhash Lala, retired Colonel0 TK Sinha, retired brigadier PK Rampal and retired deputy GOC R C Sharma.
The court has also directed the ED and the CBI to file their reply on an affidavit filed by one of the petitioners Pravin Wategaonkar alleging that Union Minister Vilasrao Deshmukh owns two proxy flats in Adarsh.
Mr Wategaonkar in his affidavit had sought CBI and ED to investigate against Deshmukh and union minister Sushil Kumar Shinde.
The court has directed the agencies to file their reply by June 18 on the allegations.
Meanwhile, another bench of the High Court admitted the petition filed by Ministry of Defence seeking demolition of the 31-storey plush building in south Mumbai on the ground that it poses a security threat to the defence installations near the building.
A division bench of Justices SJ Vazifdar and AR Joshi posted the petition for final hearing beyond summer vacation.
The interim order directing the government to not grant any permission to the society will continue till final disposal of the petition.
Track Latest News Live on NDTV.com and get news updates from India and around the world
