This Article is From Dec 10, 2019

Parliament Winter Session Highlights: Citizenship Amendment Bill Passed In Lok Sabha, 311 Votes In Favour

The lower house voted on the introduction of Citizenship Amendment Bill in the house with 293 MPs voting yes, 82 MPs voted no earlier in the day

Advertisement
India News Edited by

Citizenship Bill: Amit Shah said that the Bill is not against any minorities.

Citizenship Amendment Bill was passed in Lok Sabha with 311 votes in favour, after a detailed day-long discussion in the house. Amid protests, Union Home Minister Amit Shah on Monday had introduced the Citizenship Amendment Bill in the Lok Sabha. "The bill is not against minorities," Mr Shah said adding "they are open to answer each aspect of the bill in the house".

The lower house voted on the introduction of the bill in the house with 293 MPs voting yes, 82 MPs voted no, earlier in the day.  Widespread protests have been reported in the Northeast against what many of its residents claim is a move to nullify a decades-old accord aimed at stemming illegal immigration. 

Amit Shah also mentioned that Manipur will now be included in the Inner Line Permit (ILP) system, "this big issue has now been resolved".

Mr Shah will introduce the bill to amend the six-decade-old Citizenship Act this afternoon, after which it would be taken up for discussion and passage. The legislation seeks to make it easier for non-Muslim refugees from Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan to gain citizenship in the country.

Here are the highlights on Parliament winter session:

Dec 10, 2019 00:13 (IST)
PM Modi Thanks Amit Shah
Dec 10, 2019 00:12 (IST)
Thank the various MPs and parties that supported the Bill: PM Modi
Dec 10, 2019 00:08 (IST)
Citizenship Amendment Bill Passed In Lok Sabha
Dec 10, 2019 00:04 (IST)
Dec 09, 2019 23:56 (IST)
The division of votes on the Citizenship (Amendment) Bill is underway in the Lok Sabha.  Amit Shah completed his address and house is voting on the proposed amendment to the Citizenship Bill. 
Advertisement
Dec 09, 2019 22:39 (IST)
Home Minister Amit Shah addresses the Lok Sabha after a long discussion on the provisions of the Citizenship (Amendment) Bill
  • 48 members have participated in the discussion. 
  • The Bill is not unconstitutional "Because of reasonable classifications in Article 14, this Bill is not against the constitution." 
  • I have earlier also said that on basis of reasonable classification, there is no stoppage from article 14  
  • Partition  on religious lines has necessitated the Bill 
  • 130 crore Indians have endorsed the Bill 
  • Muslims went to Pakistan and then India was formed, Bangladesh was formed. Amid border crossing rape, loot, mishappenings took place. After this, Jawaharlal Nehru and Liaqat's understanding came which enabled in the thought process that both countries take care of its minorities
  • In 1947, minorities in Pakistan was 23% and reduced to 3.7%
  • Where did they go? Either they were killed or converted.
  • There were 9.8% Muslims. We have not done discrimination over this
  • In 1991, Hindu population was 84% and in 2011, it was 79%. In 1991, Muslim population was 9.8% but today it's 14.23%. We have not discriminated on basis of religion
  • If there are crimes against minorities in neighbouring nations, then India will not remain silent
  • In Article 14, the provisions are all for minorities. If this were done only for Christians, or only for Sikhs, then it was violation of the Article. 
  • If it is for minority protection, it is not in violation. 
  • If laws like this cannot be made, how are schools for minorities made then?
  • I repeat what Rajnath Singh said. There is no need for refugee policy. Referring to Manish Tewari's analogy, Mr Shah says the Congress leader forgot that they had also escaped religious persecution
  • You said we don't regard citizens of PoK. You don't know history: Amit Shah to Dayanidhi Maran 
  • I had also said that at different times, Citizenship has been given in Sri Lanka, Bangladesh 
  • Rohingyas wont be accepted. I will say it again
  • Attacking politician Abhishek Banerjee, Mr Shah said, "I heard him first time. Maybe this was the first time he spoke."
  • Don't you want lakhs of Bengalis and Hindus to get citizenship?
  • Nobody should be in fear, whether you have Ration card or not
  • Some parties spread rumor that they can help people get citizenship
  • Pakistan occupied Kashmir (PoK) is ours, people there are also ours. Even today, we have reserved 24 seats for them in the Jammu & Kashmir assembly
  • There is difference between Article 370 and 371. Let me assure you, we will never touch Article 371
  • There is a difference between a refugee and an infiltrator. Those who come here due to persecution, to save their religion and the honour of women, family, they are refugees and those who come here illegally are infiltrators.
  • Muslims are not minorities there, so we're not giving. If Nehru-Liaquat understanding was adopted, this wouldn't be necessary
  • All of Arunachal, Mizoram protected by inner line permit. Same Tripura, Meghalya, almost all. 
  • All of Nagaland, except a small part of Dimapur is also protected by Inner Line Permit, they too have nothing to worry
  • For Assam, a committee has been formed, sending report soon.
Dec 09, 2019 22:34 (IST)
Why don't we add names of Muslims? There are cases of Muslims being persecuted within their religion. I'll give you example of Ahmadiyya community in Punjab, Qadian is their HQ all over the world. They're minority Muslims in Pakistan, says Sukhbir Singh Badal
Dec 09, 2019 22:00 (IST)
Dec 09, 2019 20:30 (IST)
AIMIM leader Asaduddin Owaisi tore a copy of Citizenship Amendment Bill 2019 in Lok Sabha
Dec 09, 2019 19:46 (IST)
Bill does not discriminate: Chirag Paswan
We should understand why this bill was bought. This Bill has nothing to do with minorities of India and there is religious persecution of minorities abroad. In 2014, there were rumours spread that there will be riots, attack against minorities. The amount the country was secure past few years, it wasn't as secure throughout history, Chirag Paswan said. 
Dec 09, 2019 19:39 (IST)
A separate discriminatory law is not needed: Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury
Congress leader Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury, while opposing the Citizenship (Amendment) Bill, said his party is opposing the fact that the Bill is being extended on the basis of religion. 

Dec 09, 2019 19:27 (IST)
Party will support the Bill but the government should include a provision to provide refuge to Sri Lankan minorities as well: BJD leader Prasanna Acharya
Dec 09, 2019 19:24 (IST)
Please withdraw this Bill: Supriya Sule
  • We debated Article 370 and everyone on this side almost humiliated Jawaharlal Nehru by saying he did this in isolation
  • If 370 was decided in isolation, then why are we doing it for this?
  • What was urgency of this Bill? could we have not found one bill equal for all? 
  • Why is Nepal left out? So many in Nepal, Sri Lanka, Myanmar?
  • Why is India leaving them out and selectively including?
  • It is unfair to leave anyone out. Please don't make anyone stateless in this country.
  • I am talking of Article 14, 15 and not convinced by Home Minister
  • I appreciate you may have got it with good intentions, but huge section of society is being excluded

Dec 09, 2019 19:07 (IST)
Swami Vivekananda would be shell shocked if was here seeing this bill as it is against his idea of India. BJP's idea of India is divisive. It will be disastrous if we ignore words of Mahatma Gandhi and not heed advice of Sardar Patel: TMC leader Abhishek Banerjee 
Dec 09, 2019 18:59 (IST)
Not a single person will lose citizenship due to NRC, CAB: Mamata Banerjee
"Not a single citizen of this country will turn a refugee. Some people are trying to create panic with their political rhetoric but let me make one thing very clear there will no NRC and CAB. You cannot implement NRC or CAB on the basis of caste and religion", Mamata Banerjee
Dec 09, 2019 18:23 (IST)
Probably the fear of the West, the fear of being isolated by West has creeped into you and you had to include Christians in this bill. Also what about if Muslims from PoK want to come? What law do you have for that?:  Dayanidhi Maran, DMK in Lok Sabha 
Dec 09, 2019 18:15 (IST)
There should be no agitation against it: TR Singh, Manipur Education Minister
Dec 09, 2019 18:06 (IST)
BJP General Secy Ram Madhav on Citizenship Amendment Bill
"Citizenship Amendment Bill is for persecuted minorities who've come over to India. If they've been here for at least 5 years, they can claim Indian citizenship. We're open to providing refugee status to many people, including refugees from Sri Lanka and Pakistan," Mr Madhav said. 
Dec 09, 2019 17:47 (IST)
Citizenship Bill "Grants Rights, Doesn't Snatch It", Says Amit Shah
Dec 09, 2019 17:24 (IST)
Congress leader Manish Tewari opposes the Bill by saying that it is unconstitutional
  • We are notwithstanding fact that socialist and secular were added to the constitution, concept of secularism was very much embedded in our constitution. But this bill overturns the aspect. There is no need to ratify international law.
  • Today, the Home minister said Congress was responsible for partition. If there is anyone who took view of two nation theory, it was VD Savarkar in Hindu Mahasabha, not Congress
  • The Opposition knows why this was bought.
  •  I want to tell government, that they are going to make a huge mistake
  • When India became independent, a debate began. In August 10, 1949, Dr BR Ambedkar said, "Except one other article in draft const, i do not think any other article has given drafting committee such a headache as this article". 
  • At that time, India's constitution makers decided citizenship will be based on two types -- blood and geographic.
  • Till 2019, the law was amended eight times. But this time, what is being witnessed, wasn't being witnessed before. 
  • Article 14 says equality before law -- meaning that any person, irrespective of being Indian or not, will be seen equally under constitution, but this Bill goes against that. This means that you can, with any citizen, discriminate with respect to religion






Advertisement