New Delhi: Rahul Gandhi, sued for defamation over his comment blaming the RSS for Mahatma Gandhi's assassination, was today rebuked by the Supreme Court, which said: "You can't make collective denunciations."
Instead of cancelling the lawsuit filed by the RSS, as Mr Gandhi wants, the court today made it clear that the Congress vice president may face trial and announced a hearing on July 27.
Mr Gandhi, 45, had refused the court's suggestion last year that he apologise and settle the case.
"We have upheld the defamation law. The purpose of the law is to obey law so that there is harmony rather than anarchy," the court said, asserting that it will decide whether he should be tried for defamation.
To the argument that the defamation law flies in the face of the Constitutional right to freedom of speech, the court said: "Freedom is not crippled or cut. Everyday a writer, politician will speak something. The purpose of the law is not to turn people into litigants."
The Supreme Court also rejected Mr Gandhi's request for two weeks' time - his lawyer and senior Congress leader Kapil Sibal will be unavailable - and said someone else can represent him.
Mr Gandhi has been sued by an activist of the RSS or Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh - the ruling BJP's ideological mentor - for his comments during the 2014 national election campaign accusing the organization of "killing Gandhi".
RSS spokesperson MG Vaidya said: "The Congress had been consistently trying to spread lies and baseless allegations about RSS. Today's ruling has exposed the Congress."
In November, Mr Gandhi had refused to express regret for his comments. Mr Sibal told the court that his client would prefer to fight his case.
Mr Gandhi, whose mother Sonia is Congress chief, has not held back on his criticism of the RSS in speeches, often describing it as a dictatorial organization that is pulling the BJP-led government's strings.
Last year, Mr Gandhi attended a court hearing in Maharashtra's Bhiwandi town - where the defamation case was filed - even though the Supreme Court had said he could skip it.
Instead of cancelling the lawsuit filed by the RSS, as Mr Gandhi wants, the court today made it clear that the Congress vice president may face trial and announced a hearing on July 27.
Mr Gandhi, 45, had refused the court's suggestion last year that he apologise and settle the case.
To the argument that the defamation law flies in the face of the Constitutional right to freedom of speech, the court said: "Freedom is not crippled or cut. Everyday a writer, politician will speak something. The purpose of the law is not to turn people into litigants."
Advertisement
Mr Gandhi has been sued by an activist of the RSS or Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh - the ruling BJP's ideological mentor - for his comments during the 2014 national election campaign accusing the organization of "killing Gandhi".
Advertisement
In November, Mr Gandhi had refused to express regret for his comments. Mr Sibal told the court that his client would prefer to fight his case.
Advertisement
Last year, Mr Gandhi attended a court hearing in Maharashtra's Bhiwandi town - where the defamation case was filed - even though the Supreme Court had said he could skip it.
COMMENTS
Advertisement
BJP Accuses Congress Of Inciting Violence Against PM Modi With 'Maut' And 'Hinsa' Remarks "God-Sent For Me": Bengal Governor On Court's Order On Mamata Banerjee "No Defamatory Remarks Against Governor": High Court To Mamata Banerjee Shooter Had Trump's Face Right In Middle Of Crosshairs, Shows New Video Barack Obama Wants Joe Biden To Pull Out Of US Presidential Race: Report World's Largest Isolated Tribe Makes Rare Appearance In New Footage Delhi-San Francisco Air India Flight Diverted To Russia After Engine Glitch Congress Does Not Want Manipur Like Situation In Tripura: Gaurav Gogoi Ice-Cream Shop Owner Hospitalised After Being Shot At In Pune: Cops Track Latest News Live on NDTV.com and get news updates from India and around the world.