Kochi: Union Minister M Venkaiah Naidu today made a strong pitch for ending 'triple talaq', asking why should Indian Muslim women be denied their fundamental rights in a 'secular' country, when several Islamic countries have abolished the "draconian" practice.
The Urban Development and Information and Broadcasting minister also came down heavily on "advocates of triple talaq", accusing them of using "specious arguments to perpetuate the anachronistic practice" in the society.
Strongly condemning such advocates of triple talaq, Mr Naidu told reporters that these people were "not concerned by the havoc" it was causing in the lives of its victims, even as some of them knocked at the doors of the judiciary for relief.
"How could such draconian practices be allowed in India when matrimonial laws in Islamic countries were regulated and not considered contrary to Sharia?" the minister asked.
Recalling the statements made by Union Finance Minister Arun Jaitley on the issue, he said the former had earlier asserted that personal laws could not propagate discrimination and allow compromise with human dignity and that religion cannot dictate upon the rights of individuals.
Dismissing the allegations that a particular community was targeted by the Union Government on the issue, Mr Naidu said, "It should be noted that successive governments have amended personal laws of Hindus and Christians in tune with the demands of the changing times."
"A false propaganda is being propounded that a particular religion is being targeted," he said.
The minister said the Law Commission and the Supreme Court had sought public opinion on the triple talaq issue.
"The Government of India, after discussion, has given its opinion that triple talaq is not in the interest of women. It should end... That is the opinion of Government of India. And we have no inhibition on that. We are very clear that this practise is causing harm to the women," he said.
Noting that "any practice that leaves women socially, financially or emotionally vulnerable" is incompatible with the letter and spirit of Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution, Mr Naidu said to say that the Supreme Court had no jurisdiction to decide on such matters was simply "unacceptable".
"Any verdict or direction by the highest court of the land is binding on everybody irrespective of religion, region, sex and caste, and nobody should talk in any manner that undermines the dignity of the judiciary.
"It is unfortunate that some political parties, in their quest to safeguard their vote banks, did not even think once before brazenly supporting such regressive, retrograde and anti-women practices," he said.
Mr Naidu alleged that an attempt was also being made to create confusion among people by linking up the issue of triple talaq with that of the Uniform Civil Code.
"The main issue as regards to triple talaq is to end gender discrimination and ensure gender justice and equal rights. Let there be a wider debate on this critical issue. Distorting scriptures and defending exploitation of women in the guise of celebrating diversity should be stopped forthwith," he said, adding the need of the hour was to collectively address the issue.
"It goes without saying that all social, cultural and religious practices that do not stand the scrutiny of the law of equality should change. That is the only way India could transform into a modern and prosperous nation," Mr Naidu said.
His statement assumes significance in the wake of several Muslim organisations and leaders, including members of All India Muslim Personal Law Board stressing that the "Sharia law cannot be changed".
On October 7, the Centre had opposed in the Supreme Court the practise of triple talaq, 'nikah halala' and polygamy among Muslims and favoured a relook on grounds like gender equality and secularism.
The Ministry of Law and Justice, in its affidavit, referred to constitutional principles like gender equality, secularism, international covenants, religious practises and marital law prevalent in various Islamic countries to drive home the point that the practise of triple talaq and polygamy needed to be adjudicated upon afresh by the top court.
The Urban Development and Information and Broadcasting minister also came down heavily on "advocates of triple talaq", accusing them of using "specious arguments to perpetuate the anachronistic practice" in the society.
Strongly condemning such advocates of triple talaq, Mr Naidu told reporters that these people were "not concerned by the havoc" it was causing in the lives of its victims, even as some of them knocked at the doors of the judiciary for relief.
Recalling the statements made by Union Finance Minister Arun Jaitley on the issue, he said the former had earlier asserted that personal laws could not propagate discrimination and allow compromise with human dignity and that religion cannot dictate upon the rights of individuals.
Advertisement
"A false propaganda is being propounded that a particular religion is being targeted," he said.
Advertisement
"The Government of India, after discussion, has given its opinion that triple talaq is not in the interest of women. It should end... That is the opinion of Government of India. And we have no inhibition on that. We are very clear that this practise is causing harm to the women," he said.
Advertisement
"Any verdict or direction by the highest court of the land is binding on everybody irrespective of religion, region, sex and caste, and nobody should talk in any manner that undermines the dignity of the judiciary.
Advertisement
Mr Naidu alleged that an attempt was also being made to create confusion among people by linking up the issue of triple talaq with that of the Uniform Civil Code.
Advertisement
"It goes without saying that all social, cultural and religious practices that do not stand the scrutiny of the law of equality should change. That is the only way India could transform into a modern and prosperous nation," Mr Naidu said.
His statement assumes significance in the wake of several Muslim organisations and leaders, including members of All India Muslim Personal Law Board stressing that the "Sharia law cannot be changed".
On October 7, the Centre had opposed in the Supreme Court the practise of triple talaq, 'nikah halala' and polygamy among Muslims and favoured a relook on grounds like gender equality and secularism.
The Ministry of Law and Justice, in its affidavit, referred to constitutional principles like gender equality, secularism, international covenants, religious practises and marital law prevalent in various Islamic countries to drive home the point that the practise of triple talaq and polygamy needed to be adjudicated upon afresh by the top court.
COMMENTS
Advertisement
People Like Venkaiah Naidu "Make Our Nation Better, More Vibrant": PM Modi "Must Remember Darkness Of Emergency": Venkaiah Naidu On 17 Months In Jail Ex Vice-President Venkaiah Naidu, Actor Allu Arjun Among Early Voters In Telangana Indian Airports, Borders On Alert As Global Mpox Cases Rise: 10 Points "My Intention Was To...": Sudha Murty Clarifies Raksha Bandhan Post Flower Seller Forced To Buy iPhone For Son On Hunger Strike, Internet Reacts "Hang Him Or Do...": Mother-In-Law Of Kolkata Rape-Murder Case Accused Former Congressman George Santos Pleads Guilty To Fraud Joe Biden's Son Hunter Loses Bid To Toss Tax Evasion Case Track Latest News Live on NDTV.com and get news updates from India and around the world.