New Delhi: Justice Jasti Chelameswar, one of the four judges who had questioned the way cases are assigned in the Supreme Court, today refused to hear a related petition saying he was about to retire and didn't want "another reversal" of his order within 24 hours.
Prashant Bhushan had requested Justice Chelameswar's bench to take up his father Shanti Bhushan's petition asking that cases be allotted by a collegium or group of judges for transparency. The petition was not being accepted by the court's registry, the lawyer told the second most senior Supreme Court judge.
Mr Bhushan also said he wanted the petition to be considered by a judge other than Chief Justice Dipak Misra as he was named as a party.
"You know my difficulty, you understand my problem," replied Justice Chelameswar.
"I am going to retire in a few days. I can't hear your petition on the allocation of cases. I don't want another reversal of my order in 24 hours," said the judge, referring to an earlier case in which his order was overturned by the Chief Justice a day later.
"Someone is carrying out a tirade against me that I am waiting to grab some office. For reasons too obvious in the history of the country, I will not deal with this case. It is the problem of the county. Let the country take its own course."
After Justice Chelameswar's refusal, Prashant Bhushan raised his request before the Chief Justice, who said he would "look into it".
Former law minister Shanti Bhushan's petition challenges the Chief Justice's status as "Master of the Roster" and refers to the "extremely disturbing trend of listing matters subjectively and selectively" and "serious erosion of independence of the judiciary in deciding matters objectively and independently".
In January, Justice Chelameswar and three other judges - the top four of the country after the Chief Justice - went public with their criticism of the way sensitive cases were allocated and implied that the Chief Justice was abusing his position as "master of the roster".
The immediate trigger for their unprecedented press conference was the case involving Justice BH Loya, who died in 2012 of a cardiac arrest, at a time he was deciding on charges against BJP president Amit Shah. The case was first allotted to a junior judge.
Prashant Bhushan had requested Justice Chelameswar's bench to take up his father Shanti Bhushan's petition asking that cases be allotted by a collegium or group of judges for transparency. The petition was not being accepted by the court's registry, the lawyer told the second most senior Supreme Court judge.
"You know my difficulty, you understand my problem," replied Justice Chelameswar.
Advertisement
"Someone is carrying out a tirade against me that I am waiting to grab some office. For reasons too obvious in the history of the country, I will not deal with this case. It is the problem of the county. Let the country take its own course."
Advertisement
Former law minister Shanti Bhushan's petition challenges the Chief Justice's status as "Master of the Roster" and refers to the "extremely disturbing trend of listing matters subjectively and selectively" and "serious erosion of independence of the judiciary in deciding matters objectively and independently".
Advertisement
The immediate trigger for their unprecedented press conference was the case involving Justice BH Loya, who died in 2012 of a cardiac arrest, at a time he was deciding on charges against BJP president Amit Shah. The case was first allotted to a junior judge.
COMMENTS
Advertisement
Supreme Court To Hear Petitions Relating To NEET-UG Controversy Tomorrow Delhi Government Must Take Blame For Permission To Fell 422 Trees: Supreme Court Biden Weighing Proposals To Reform US Supreme Court? Details Inside Amid Huge Row, Karnataka Pauses Bill For Reservation In Private Sector Firms Video: Son Of Sharad Pawar's Party Leader, Allegedly Drunk, Crashes SUV Travel Influencer Aanvi Kamdar Dies After Falling Off A Waterfall Near Mumbai Indian Among 6 People Killed In Oman Mosque Shooting Coast Guard Rescues 11 From Boat In Critical Condition Off Kerala Coast Tripura Man Beheads Mother With Sharp-Edged Weapon After Fight Over Money Track Latest News Live on NDTV.com and get news updates from India and around the world.