Washington: An Alabama police officer used a violent technique, like "somebody cutting down a tree", to slam an Indian grandfather to the ground, an expert witness testified in the retrial of the cop.
Former Madison Officer Eric Parker did not use a takedown consistent with prevailing national police standards for 57-year-old Sureshbhai Patel, who had arrived days earlier from India to take care of his grandson, Captain Kenny Sanders told a Huntsville court on Thursday.
The first trial of Parker for the February 6 takedown of Mr Patel while he was taking a walk near his son's home ended early last month with a hung jury, as the jury split 10-2 in favour of acquittal. If convicted, Parker faces 10 years in federal prison.
"That was pretty violent technique that he used that day. I've never seen it," said Sanders, who testified he is the senior master instructor for police training in the state of Louisiana, according to Al.com
"Lumberjack, that's what it reminds me of, somebody cutting down a tree in their yard," he said when asked about the takedown of Mr Patel, in response to a neighbour's call about a "skinny black man" walking near homes.
The takedown left Mr Patel in need of spinal surgery and with limited ability to walk or grip with his hands.
The defence has argued Mr Patel pulled away as Parker searched him and that he could have had a deadly weapon in his pants' pockets.
"If he was trying to pull away, it still would not have equated to the type of force ... the technique is too violent," testified Sanders.
He said Mr Patel's age, size, his inability to speak English and the presence of multiple officers should have factored into the decision on how to handle Patel.
Sanders also testified he did not see a sign of a threat on the video, saying Mr Patel's legs seemed relaxed.
As for Mr Patel walking away from officer, Sanders said: "That's not really resistance."
Earlier, Captain John Stringer, an 18-year veteran of the Madison police force, said the force used by Parker had to be proportional with the actions of Mr Patel. "My conclusion was it was improper."
After the prosecution rested, Defence attorney Robert Tuten asked the judge to throw out the case saying, "They did not prove he was wilfully, intentionally violating the civil rights of Mr. Patel by using excessive force."
Assistant US Attorney Robert Posey replied that police must be "objectively reasonable" in taking steps that would be criminal assault if done by somebody else. "He's lucky he didn't kill him. This is essentially, the government would argue, deadly force."
Former Madison Officer Eric Parker did not use a takedown consistent with prevailing national police standards for 57-year-old Sureshbhai Patel, who had arrived days earlier from India to take care of his grandson, Captain Kenny Sanders told a Huntsville court on Thursday.
The first trial of Parker for the February 6 takedown of Mr Patel while he was taking a walk near his son's home ended early last month with a hung jury, as the jury split 10-2 in favour of acquittal. If convicted, Parker faces 10 years in federal prison.
"Lumberjack, that's what it reminds me of, somebody cutting down a tree in their yard," he said when asked about the takedown of Mr Patel, in response to a neighbour's call about a "skinny black man" walking near homes.
Advertisement
The defence has argued Mr Patel pulled away as Parker searched him and that he could have had a deadly weapon in his pants' pockets.
Advertisement
He said Mr Patel's age, size, his inability to speak English and the presence of multiple officers should have factored into the decision on how to handle Patel.
Advertisement
As for Mr Patel walking away from officer, Sanders said: "That's not really resistance."
Advertisement
After the prosecution rested, Defence attorney Robert Tuten asked the judge to throw out the case saying, "They did not prove he was wilfully, intentionally violating the civil rights of Mr. Patel by using excessive force."
Advertisement
COMMENTS
Advertisement
US Woman Arrested For Sitting On 10-Year-Old Foster Son, Who Died 2 Days Later Centre Nominates Ex Foreign Secretary Vinay Kwatra As US Ambassador To Secure Ties Trump's Fossil Fuel Agenda Gets Priority Over Climate Change At Convention Amid Huge Row, Karnataka Pauses Bill For Reservation In Private Sector Firms "Relocate To Vizag": Andhra Minister To IT Firms Amid Karnataka Quota Row "I Divorce You... Your Ex-Wife": Dubai Princess Dumps Husband In Insta Post Amid Huge Row, Karnataka Pauses Bill For Reservation In Private Sector Firms "Animal Cruelty": Abu Dhabi's First Owl Cafe Goes Viral, Internet Angry Madras High Court's Big Rebuke To Probe Agency In Illegal Sand Mining Row Track Latest News Live on NDTV.com and get news updates from India and around the world.