An Indian-origin former student, convicted for spying on his gay roommate who then committed suicide, could see his conviction for bias intimidation reversed after the New Jersey Supreme Court ruled that the state's law in this regard was unconstitutional.
The court last week struck down a portion of the state's bias crime statute that could win Dharun Ravi a new trial in the Tyler Clementi webcam case, his attorney said.
According to the earlier state statute on bias intimidation, defendants can be convicted of bias intimidation if their victims "reasonably believed" they were harassed or intimidated because of their race, colour, gender, ethnicity, religion or sexual orientation.
The ruling said that it is the defendant's intent and state of mind that is important, not the victim's.
The appeal of Ravi's 2012 guilty verdict that included several bias intimidation charges is still ongoing.
Now retired, Judge Berman permitted the prosecution to produce evidence of Clementi's state of mind to the jury.
Judge Berman also prohibited Mr Altman from obtaining some items seized from Clementi's possessions and computer, including the suicide note, Mr Altman was quoted as saying.
"The evidence about Tyler Clementi's state-of-mind. Did that prejudice the jury?"
The Supreme Court justices said in the 36-page decision that, "whether a victim reasonably believes he was targeted for a bias crime will necessarily be informed by the victim's individual experiences and distinctive cultural, historical, and familial heritage - all of which may be unknown or unknowable to the defendant."
Altman said he intends to include that language in additional papers he will now file with the appeals court because there was no way for Mr Ravi to know Clementi's emotional state at the time of the incidents.
Mr Ravi was sentenced to a 30 days in jail, three years' of supervised release, ordered to do 300 hours of community service and pay a fine of about $11,000 after he was convicted in March 2012 of using a webcam to spy on the sexual encounters of Clementi in September 2010.
Clementi committed suicide days later.
Mr Ravi was released from prison after serving 20 days.
India vs Australia 1st ODI Highlights: Mohammed Shami, Shubman Gill Shine In India's Five-Wicket Win Over Australia 'Don't Have Any Other Work?': Ex-Pakistan Captain Slams England, Australian PMs Over Jonny Bairstow Saga ENG vs AUS, 3rd Ashes Test Highlights: Mitchell Marsh, Pat Cummins Put Australia In Control Against England Phone Data Bought For Rs 2,500 Used For Multi-Crore Scam Running In Noida BMW Dash By Shinde Sena Leader's Son Led To Mumbai Woman's Death In Mumbai Hit-And-Run, Speeding BMW Dragged Woman For 100 Metres Need Plan To Control Immigration: Ex UK PM Blair's Advice To Keir Starmer Could Kamala Harris Beat Trump In US Presidential Race? Polls Suggest... CUET UG 2024 Provisional Answer Key Released, Raise Objections Until July 9 Track Latest News Live on NDTV.com and get news updates from India and around the world.