(Ashok Malik is a columnist and writer living in Delhi.)
It was in the mid-1980s that Margaret Thatcher famously spoke of denying terrorists the "oxygen of publicity". True, this was and is easier said than done. Terrorists - or even every day criminals - resort to actions that are newsy by their occurrence and a certain share of the headlines and of prime time is inevitable.
Yet, some decisions are not as clear-cut. A documentary film-maker's interview of Mukesh Singh, one of the six men who raped and caused the death of a Delhi paramedic on December 16, 2012, leaves one with mixed feelings. By all accounts, the documentary cannot be accused of glamorising him, as previous interviews of killers such as Charles Manson, who murdered the pregnant movie star Sharon Tate in 1969, were charged with doing. Nevertheless, the documentary has allowed Singh to more or less traduce his victim and make completely obnoxious and unacceptable remarks about women in general and the person he brutalised in particular.
Ultimately the choice of interviewing a disreputable, downright evil subject and placing his words and actions in an appropriate context is that of the journalist or film-maker. It is a subjective call. For instance, Ram Gopal Varma made an appalling film (Not a Love Story) on the Neeraj Grover murder case that was voyeuristic and did little but attempt to titillate.
Having said that, the demand for a ban or a restriction in telecast - whether placed by the executive or the judiciary - is silly and anyway impracticable. Those who suggest India's reputation and tourism potential will be damaged by the film make no sense. Indian authorities cannot possibly stop release of the film in other countries. As for Indians themselves, let them watch the film - or not watch it, if they so want - and think for themselves. They don't need the nanny state.
To apply that standard to a documentary that seeks to interrogate a pressing social phenomenon - safety of women, at least safety of women in urban areas in India; attitudes towards women and rape, as expressed by not just Singh but also his lawyers, even outside the court-room, in a private capacity - is ridiculous.
As it happens, this "Daddy knows best" attitude of governments and those in authority is becoming distressingly familiar in India. The newly-announced censor board has made a laughing stock of itself by framing a list of allegedly "objectionable" words that would amount to sanitising cinema. Some years ago, as information and broadcasting minister, Priyaranjan Das Munishi actually held up the release of Da Vinci Code even after the film certification authorities had cleared it. He said the film would only be shown to the public when he (Das Munshi) had watched it in the company of Catholic priests and secured their blessing.
"Throughout his celebrated Salt March ... and later campaigns," wrote Thomas Weber in Going Native, his book on Gandhi's interaction with a series of western women, "the focus was not merely on an India free from the British, but a certain sort of India - one that was free from the blemishes pointed out in Mother India ... The amount of energy he spent on commenting on the book, even years later, shows an almost obsessive relationship with Katherine Mayo and Mother India."
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed within this article are the personal opinions of the author. NDTV is not responsible for the accuracy, completeness, suitability, or validity of any information on this article. All information is provided on an as-is basis. The information, facts or opinions appearing in the article do not reflect the views of NDTV and NDTV does not assume any responsibility or liability for the same.
Row Over Arvind Kejriwal's Letter To VK Saxena On I-Day Flag Hoisting AAP vs Tihar Jail On Arvind Kejriwal's Weight Loss, Drop In Blood Sugar Arvind Kejriwal Sent To 14-Day Judicial Custody In Delhi Liquor Policy Case Vandalism At Kolkata Hospital Where Doctor Was Raped, Tear Gas Fired Starbucks' Indian-Origin CEO, Recently Fired, Never Worked Past 6 pm 150 mg Semen In Kolkata Doctor's Body, Suspect Gang-Rape: Parents To Court Delhi Airport Becomes 1st To Achieve Net Zero Carbon Emission Status US Welcomes India's Engagement In War Between Russia, Ukraine Google Says Iran Hackers Target Trump, Kamala Harris Campaigns Track Latest News Live on NDTV.com and get news updates from India and around the world.