Debate Rages on Over Ban on Beauty Contests in Tamil Nadu Colleges

The Madras High Court's recent order, directing the Tamil Nadu government to ban fashion shows and beauty contests in educational institutions, has drawn mixed reactions from students and teachers. While some have argued that participating in such contests should be a matter of personal choice, others have lauded the ruling as they believe such shows are in bad taste.

The order - delivered on February 5 - says it's unclear "how walking the ramp would benefit a student pursuing a course in engineering."

The court could have "regulated the events," said Sujatha Poorani, a student, adding, "Why ban them?"

Jenefa, a professor, believes that "It's an individual's choice. The court or state should not interfere".  

But some believe the court took the right decision. Archana, a student, believes that such shows and contests are "often in bad taste in terms of costumes and content, triggering bad behaviour on campuses".

Subha Venkatesh, an IT professional, also welcomed the ban, saying, "Students just try to ape western culture in these shows". Meera, a student, argues, "The ban is good as these shows divert students from academics".

But those not in favour of the ban also point out that fashion shows and beauty contests provide a good opportunity for those aspiring for a career in the fashion industry.

"These shows could open up many career prospects for young creative minds in the fields of fashion, modeling and photography. They build confidence and banning them is not a good idea," says Deepa Santhanam, a teacher.

After graduating from college, such an avenue may not be available again, says Shruti Dugar, a student of Architecture.  

The ban may not withstand legal scrutiny on appeal, believe many, adding that it may be overturned in the final order. The court will hear the matter again on the 20th of this month.