Prannoy Roy And Experts Analyse Economic Survey 2022 | Read
Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman tabled the Economic Survey 2021-2022 in Parliament today. India will see economic growth of 8 to 8.5 per cent in the coming fiscal year, down from 9.2 per cent growth estimated in the current year, the annual Survey predicted a day before the Budget.
Almost all indicators show that the economic impact of the "second wave" in the first quarter was much smaller than that experienced during the full lockdown phase in 2020-21 even though the health impact was more severe, the survey notes.
Prannoy Roy and experts decode the annual Survey.
Highlights:
Frontline Workers Essential In Getting Children Back To Schools: World Bank India Country Director
20-24 per cent children will not come back to schools post-pandemic, particularly girls. We are seeing it in Latin America, Africa, South Asia. The frontline is extremely important - aanganwadis, Asha workers - in getting the students back to schools. We need to chase the virus. Southeast Asia need a regional surveillance system that can anticipate the disease: Junaid Ahmad, World Bank India, Country Director.
Services like travel, tourism, restaurant, parlours suffered more. The fear factor stopped people from stepping out. The only way out is to get vaccinated. The major reason for the slowdown was the capex slowdown since 2011-12. We need reforms - in tax, capital control - to get businesses up: Economist Dr Ila Patnaik.
We require more investments by big companies and formalisation of the economy to strengthen the economy. We need the investments to come in fast: Mahesh Vyas. MD & CEO, CMIE
Need To Put More Disposable Income In Hands Of People To Boost Demand: Kiran Mazumdar Shaw
We need to double up per capita income. We need to put more disposable income in the hands of poeple to boost demand. There is a huge economic strain. We need to look at the bond market and other fiscal measures.We are doing a lot but not doing enough. Pandemic has shown that we can we things in a smart way. We are sitting on huge amount of data. But we are not really connecting the dots to give us insights into the data. We need to have a sensible approach: Kiran Mazumdar Shaw.
The way we have failed says two things: government speaks of disinvestments, but they don't and nobody in the government wants it. Npobody thinks that the government wants privatisations. There's lot of talk but no belief: Economist Dr Omkar Goswami.
80% expenditure on pre-committed items. Flexibility on budget is on 20% of expenditure. The flexibility falls down to what one can achieve through disinvestments. The picture for this year is not as gloomy as you are painting it to be: Dr Samiran Chakraborty, Chief Economist, CITI Group.
Any type of fiscal measure must deal with the supply side. Budget deficit vs inflation is a false dilemma: Junaid Ahmad, World Bank India, Country Director.
2021 was the year of policy reinforcement. 2022 must be the year the fiscal policy becomes supportive. We need a budget that focuses on growth. The most important thing is to spend on public investment and infrastructure. We saw 21% growth in infra spending. We need more of this: Sajjid Chinoy, Chief Economist, JP Morgan.
The tax to GDP ratio must be high. Our ratio is very very low. But who will pay for it? Two years from now, you won't have a tight budget because it is an election year. Next year will be a year that is close to the elections. So it will again be a tight budget. So, where will the corrections come in?: Economist Dr Omkar Goswami.
We have to focus on this strata of society. Can we look at minimum income of people who have plunged into poverty? Divestment must happen. We need to look at fiscal reforms - we are doing it too slow. There is demand. We are so underinvested in R&D that we can't look at growth: Kiran Mazumdar Shaw.
We have to open up the economy and take courage and confidence in the fact that vaccines are preventing disease. The MSME and services sector must open up. We need to open up the markets. We need to privatise it. We are long past vaccine adequacy. We need to open up vaccine export. Else, we won't see the economic recovery we want to: Kiran Mazumdar Shaw.
Economic activities back to pre-pandemic levels but not in proportion to the population: Sajjid Chinoy
There is a virtous cycle in the formal sector and viscious cycle in informal sector. People in the formal sector have held on to their jobs. But that is not the case in informal setor. We need a massive boost in jobs in the informal sector: Dr Samiran Chakraborty
We need to get jobs back. Jobs must come back to the services sector and the MSME sector: Kiran Mazumdar Shaw
Congress has not been as good as we expected. Today, half of India's agriculture is irrigated. 99% in Punjab. Just increasing irrigatioon cover is not enough. We need to learn to use water for irrigation. We need to increase investment in irrigation. We gace four times the buffer food stock we need: Dr Ashok Gulati, agricultural economist
It is a difficult situation facing most countries. The economic survey is out. The growth prediction is high. 9.2% GDP growth prediction is based on data from the first half of the year: Dr Montek Singh Ahluwalia
The Economic Survey says 8-8.5% growth next year. But the question is whether 8.5% is likely? in the first half, the economy grew 13%. Therefore, in the second half, they are projecting less than a five percent growth mark. How do we take it up to 8-8.5%?: Dr Montek Singh Ahluwalia
During the UPA, it was called disinvestment. The political composition of UPA didn't approve of the word "privatisation". It doesn't happen because the bureaucrats who have to do it are afraid that they have to sell at a lesser price: Dr Montek Singh Ahluwalia
India has been maybe a little more affected than elsewhere by the pandemic. Even leading up to the pandemic, the economy was weak: Dr Arvind Subramanian
The slowdown has one big scar. MNREGA demand today is 40-50% more than pre-pandemic levels. That has in a sense left a deep scar in terms of the jobs crisis. The digital infra has improved. Recently, we have had exports that we should acknowledge. The privatisation of Air India is a big signature achievement: Dr Arvind Subramanian
There is a historic opportunity for India today. After the global financial crisis, China became uncompetitive. Now is the 2nd opportunity - investors are fleeing China for geopolitical reasons and places like Vietnam because of its zero-Covid policy cannot take its place. So there is a historic opportunity: Dr Arvind Subramanian
We really need to push Atmanirbharta. Fundamental trust in investors is needed. Indians think we have a big market and investors will come here. But the consumption market is small. So we need to have prices that are globally competitive: Dr Arvind Subramanian
Almost all indicators show that the economic impact of the "second wave" in the first quarter was much smaller than that experienced during the full lockdown phase in 2020-21 even though the health impact was more severe, the survey notes.
Prannoy Roy and experts decode the annual Survey.
Highlights:
Frontline Workers Essential In Getting Children Back To Schools: World Bank India Country Director
20-24 per cent children will not come back to schools post-pandemic, particularly girls. We are seeing it in Latin America, Africa, South Asia. The frontline is extremely important - aanganwadis, Asha workers - in getting the students back to schools. We need to chase the virus. Southeast Asia need a regional surveillance system that can anticipate the disease: Junaid Ahmad, World Bank India, Country Director.
Services like travel, tourism, restaurant, parlours suffered more. The fear factor stopped people from stepping out. The only way out is to get vaccinated. The major reason for the slowdown was the capex slowdown since 2011-12. We need reforms - in tax, capital control - to get businesses up: Economist Dr Ila Patnaik.
We require more investments by big companies and formalisation of the economy to strengthen the economy. We need the investments to come in fast: Mahesh Vyas. MD & CEO, CMIE
Need To Put More Disposable Income In Hands Of People To Boost Demand: Kiran Mazumdar Shaw
We need to double up per capita income. We need to put more disposable income in the hands of poeple to boost demand. There is a huge economic strain. We need to look at the bond market and other fiscal measures.We are doing a lot but not doing enough. Pandemic has shown that we can we things in a smart way. We are sitting on huge amount of data. But we are not really connecting the dots to give us insights into the data. We need to have a sensible approach: Kiran Mazumdar Shaw.
The way we have failed says two things: government speaks of disinvestments, but they don't and nobody in the government wants it. Npobody thinks that the government wants privatisations. There's lot of talk but no belief: Economist Dr Omkar Goswami.
80% expenditure on pre-committed items. Flexibility on budget is on 20% of expenditure. The flexibility falls down to what one can achieve through disinvestments. The picture for this year is not as gloomy as you are painting it to be: Dr Samiran Chakraborty, Chief Economist, CITI Group.
Any type of fiscal measure must deal with the supply side. Budget deficit vs inflation is a false dilemma: Junaid Ahmad, World Bank India, Country Director.
2021 was the year of policy reinforcement. 2022 must be the year the fiscal policy becomes supportive. We need a budget that focuses on growth. The most important thing is to spend on public investment and infrastructure. We saw 21% growth in infra spending. We need more of this: Sajjid Chinoy, Chief Economist, JP Morgan.
The tax to GDP ratio must be high. Our ratio is very very low. But who will pay for it? Two years from now, you won't have a tight budget because it is an election year. Next year will be a year that is close to the elections. So it will again be a tight budget. So, where will the corrections come in?: Economist Dr Omkar Goswami.
We have to focus on this strata of society. Can we look at minimum income of people who have plunged into poverty? Divestment must happen. We need to look at fiscal reforms - we are doing it too slow. There is demand. We are so underinvested in R&D that we can't look at growth: Kiran Mazumdar Shaw.
We have to open up the economy and take courage and confidence in the fact that vaccines are preventing disease. The MSME and services sector must open up. We need to open up the markets. We need to privatise it. We are long past vaccine adequacy. We need to open up vaccine export. Else, we won't see the economic recovery we want to: Kiran Mazumdar Shaw.
Economic activities back to pre-pandemic levels but not in proportion to the population: Sajjid Chinoy
There is a virtous cycle in the formal sector and viscious cycle in informal sector. People in the formal sector have held on to their jobs. But that is not the case in informal setor. We need a massive boost in jobs in the informal sector: Dr Samiran Chakraborty
We need to get jobs back. Jobs must come back to the services sector and the MSME sector: Kiran Mazumdar Shaw
Congress has not been as good as we expected. Today, half of India's agriculture is irrigated. 99% in Punjab. Just increasing irrigatioon cover is not enough. We need to learn to use water for irrigation. We need to increase investment in irrigation. We gace four times the buffer food stock we need: Dr Ashok Gulati, agricultural economist
It is a difficult situation facing most countries. The economic survey is out. The growth prediction is high. 9.2% GDP growth prediction is based on data from the first half of the year: Dr Montek Singh Ahluwalia
The Economic Survey says 8-8.5% growth next year. But the question is whether 8.5% is likely? in the first half, the economy grew 13%. Therefore, in the second half, they are projecting less than a five percent growth mark. How do we take it up to 8-8.5%?: Dr Montek Singh Ahluwalia
During the UPA, it was called disinvestment. The political composition of UPA didn't approve of the word "privatisation". It doesn't happen because the bureaucrats who have to do it are afraid that they have to sell at a lesser price: Dr Montek Singh Ahluwalia
India has been maybe a little more affected than elsewhere by the pandemic. Even leading up to the pandemic, the economy was weak: Dr Arvind Subramanian
The slowdown has one big scar. MNREGA demand today is 40-50% more than pre-pandemic levels. That has in a sense left a deep scar in terms of the jobs crisis. The digital infra has improved. Recently, we have had exports that we should acknowledge. The privatisation of Air India is a big signature achievement: Dr Arvind Subramanian
There is a historic opportunity for India today. After the global financial crisis, China became uncompetitive. Now is the 2nd opportunity - investors are fleeing China for geopolitical reasons and places like Vietnam because of its zero-Covid policy cannot take its place. So there is a historic opportunity: Dr Arvind Subramanian
We really need to push Atmanirbharta. Fundamental trust in investors is needed. Indians think we have a big market and investors will come here. But the consumption market is small. So we need to have prices that are globally competitive: Dr Arvind Subramanian
