The controversy over why a young woman was spied upon by some of Gujarat's most senior police officers is defunct, the BJP claimed today. The Congress has alleged that the illegal surveillance was commissioned in 2009 by the BJP's prime ministerial candidate, Narendra Modi, and that his close aide and then Home Minister Amit Shah assigned top policemen and even members of the anti-terror squad to stalking the woman. We debate: Is the snooping row about privacy or politics? And does it intensify the sahebzada vs shehzada battle?