Afghan panel claims to find secret prisons

Kabul: A commission appointed by President Hamid Karzai to investigate detention facilities run by U.S. and British forces in southern Afghanistan claimed Saturday to have uncovered secret prisons on two coalition bases, an allegation that could not be immediately confirmed but that was likely to further complicate relations between the Afghan government and its allies.

"We have conducted a thorough investigation and search of Kandahar Airfield and Camp Bastion and found several illegal and unlawful detention facilities run and operated by foreign military forces," said Abdul Shakur Dadras, the panel's chairman.

Dadras offered no evidence to support his assertion, though he promised to release more details after presenting his report to Karzai.

Lt. Col. J. Todd Breasseale, a spokesman for the Defense Department, wrote in an email, "Every facility that we use for detention is well known not only by the Government of the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan, but also by the ICRC," a reference to the International Committee of the Red Cross, a nonpartisan organization that provides humanitarian care for victims of conflict.

The International Security Assistance Force, or ISAF, as the coalition is known, said in a statement Saturday that it was "aware of their investigative team looking into the detention facilities in Kandahar and Helmand and we are cooperating fully with the investigation on this matter."

The accusations are the latest salvo in a dispute over the detention of Afghans by foreign forces. The issue reached a climax early this year, when the Afghan government released from the former U.S. prison at Bagram dozens of prisoners the coalition claimed had killed U.S. soldiers.

Before that, the transfer of the prison itself called attention to the deteriorating relationship between the Afghans and their U.S. allies in a public way.


U.S. has accused the Afghan government of using the issue to score political points. The Afghans say the foreigners have unfairly imprisoned people without credible evidence and insist that they run all detention facilities in the country.

Dadras said his team was sent to the southern provinces of Kandahar and Helmand to review the prisons on two coalition bases, Kandahar Airfield, run by the United States, and Camp Bastion, run by the British.

He said his team had reviewed the number of prisoners as well as the details of their detention. The issue at Camp Bastion has been aired before. The British military must abide by rules that prohibit the transfer of prisoners to facilities where torture is believed to occur. For now, that concern is unresolved, and the sites where these detainees are held by the British forces could be the locations Dadras is referring to.

In Kandahar, the details are less clear. U.S. forces are allowed to detain combatants seized on the battlefield for up to 96 hours before turning them over to the Afghan government. It was unclear whether Dadras was referring to such detainees or whether his commission had uncovered evidence of prisons that were illegally holding Afghans.

Early Saturday, a coalition helicopter crashed after it malfunctioned in Kandahar, killing five service members. The coalition did not release the nationalities of the soldiers. Britain's Defense Ministry said the helicopter was British but could not confirm the nationalities of the dead, according to The Associated Press.

Officials on Saturday also identified two of the three Americans killed Thursday when an Afghan police officer shot a group of Americans at a hospital in Kabul. The third victim was identified Thursday.

The two men identified Saturday were John Gabel, who was a health clinic administrator at Kabul University, and his father, Gary, who was visiting. They were killed alongside Jerry Umanos, a pediatric doctor who worked at the Cure International Hospital in Kabul. The officials said Jon Gabel's wife was wounded in the attack.