New York: An Indian-origin law student is suing Manhattan's top federal prosecutor Preet Bharara and the US Justice Department claiming she was unlawfully questioned, and her cell phone confiscated after she sent letters to the presiding judge during Rajat Gupta's insider trading trial.
24-year-old Benula Bensam, who regularly attended the trial of ex-McKinsey head Gupta, has filed a 16-page lawsuit against Bharara, prosecutors Reed Brodsky, Richard Tarlowe and the US Marshals Service in US District Court.
Bensam had got into trouble during Gupta trial last month after she sent three letters to Judge Jed Rakoff on the case.
A law student at the Benjamin Cardozo School of Law, Bensam said she had taken a class on 'Federal Rules of Evidence' during her last semester and the letters to Rakoff focussed on the various rulings he had made in the case and were not intended to influence him.
She said in the lawsuit that she wanted to "understand the process of litigation" and intended to follow the case on a "general level".
"At no point had anyone informed me that I must not direct letters about the ongoing trial, or about the evidentiary rules or about any other matter to Judge Rakoff," she said in the lawsuit.
During one of the court proceedings in June, Bensam was escorted out of the courtroom by US Marshals and questioned over the letters she had sent to the judge. Marshals questioned her at length and refused to return her cell phone saying she could get it back only after she had answered all their questions, she said.
The Marshals also attempted to take her picture with a mobile phone. She later decided to go home and refused to answer any questions.
She returned to the court next day to get her phone back. She also alleged that her phone had been switched on by the court security.
She also alleges that she was subjected to "unreasonable search and seizure for unlawful stop, detention, interrogation, seizure of property, search of property, search of communications and demand for identification."
She is representing herself in the lawsuit.
"It is not a crime for a disinterested party to write letters to a judge on the subject of a trial," the lawsuit said. "The US Marshals are to be held responsible for actions taken by court security officers for their role in the seizure of my phone," Bensam said in the lawsuit.
She added that Bharara as well as the prosecutors in the Gupta case had "instigated the involvement of the US Marshals".
According to rules of the US District Court in Manhattan, members of the public are not allowed to take cell phones and electronic devices into the court and must deposit them with court security.
Later during a break in the court's proceedings, Bensam was asked to go up to Rakoff's bench for a private conference with him and the lawyers.
Bensam said the judge had politely asked her not to send any letters to him as any communication might be perceived as an attempt by her to influence him on the outcome of the case.
24-year-old Benula Bensam, who regularly attended the trial of ex-McKinsey head Gupta, has filed a 16-page lawsuit against Bharara, prosecutors Reed Brodsky, Richard Tarlowe and the US Marshals Service in US District Court.
Bensam had got into trouble during Gupta trial last month after she sent three letters to Judge Jed Rakoff on the case.
She said in the lawsuit that she wanted to "understand the process of litigation" and intended to follow the case on a "general level".
Advertisement
During one of the court proceedings in June, Bensam was escorted out of the courtroom by US Marshals and questioned over the letters she had sent to the judge. Marshals questioned her at length and refused to return her cell phone saying she could get it back only after she had answered all their questions, she said.
Advertisement
She returned to the court next day to get her phone back. She also alleged that her phone had been switched on by the court security.
Advertisement
She is representing herself in the lawsuit.
Advertisement
She added that Bharara as well as the prosecutors in the Gupta case had "instigated the involvement of the US Marshals".
Advertisement
Later during a break in the court's proceedings, Bensam was asked to go up to Rakoff's bench for a private conference with him and the lawyers.
Bensam said the judge had politely asked her not to send any letters to him as any communication might be perceived as an attempt by her to influence him on the outcome of the case.
COMMENTS
Advertisement
Tesla CEO Elon Musk Faces Shareholder Lawsuit for Alleged $7.5 Billion Insider Trading Indian-American Ex-Pfizer Employee Charged With Insider Trading On Covid Pill British Billionaire Joe Lewis Pleads Guilty To Insider Trading Charges In US Nurse Raped, Killed On Way Home, Body Found 9 Days Later In UP "Don't Expect Anything From Me": Kolkata Hospital's New Principal Loses Cool Rahul Gandhi's Seat At Red Fort Triggers Fresh Congress Attack On BJP Left, BJP, Creating Unrest: Mamata Banerjee On Midnight Attack At Hospital 'Don't Club Us With Others,' Says Manipur's Thadou Tribe, Waits For Peace Plan More Monkey Pox Cases Likely To Hit Europe Soon, Says WHO Track Latest News Live on NDTV.com and get news updates from India and around the world.