NDTV Analysis: No Arab Support, Hamas Stands Tall - Donald Trump's Gaza Plan Hurdle

US President Donald Trump stood on a podium at the White House. Flanked by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who kept his gaze locked on Trump, the President delivered a proposal with characteristic bravado that would decide the fate of over 2 million people in a besieged territory around 9,500 km away. "The US will take over the Gaza Strip, and we will do a job with it," President Trump declared. But his declaration failed to answer a massive question: What about Hamas?
The armed Palestinian group, designated a terrorist organisation by the US, maintains a stronghold in Gaza and has ruled the enclave since 2007. It's October 7 attacks on Israel in 2023 was followed by the Israelis launching a devastating attack on Gaza which has led to the deaths of over 50,000 and displacement of millions.
In his proposal, Trump offered no details on how his administration would handle Hamas or the implications of a US intervention in yet another country in the Middle East under turmoil.
"We will own it and be responsible for dismantling all of the dangerous unexploded bombs and other weapons on the site. Level the site and get rid of the destroyed buildings. Level it out," Trump said.
Netanyahu, standing beside Trump at the press conference, appeared pleased.
Trump has floated an idea that has stunned international observers: the idea that the United States could "own" Gaza after the war and resettle its Palestinian population elsewhere in the Middle East. His remarks have drawn sharp condemnation from Palestinian groups, Arab nations, and international experts, raising questions about the feasibility of his vision.
Hamas Still Stands
Hamas remains a force in Gaza. Despite months of Israeli bombardment and ground operations aimed at dismantling it, Hamas has neither been eliminated nor driven out of the enclave. Its continued presence complicates any proposal for Gaza's future-whether from Trump or any other political leader.
Hamas controls underground tunnel networks, maintains military capability, and continues to influence the population. While Netanyahu has vowed to destroy the group, that objective remains far from realised. Some analysts believe that completely eradicating Hamas could take years - if it is possible at all.
Trump has said that he does not want fighting to resume after the current ceasefire, yet his plan offers no realistic mechanism for removing Hamas from Gaza. Without a clear solution, his proposal faces immediate practical obstacles:
The Israeli military, after months of operations, has not fully dismantled the group. It is unlikely that any Arab country would commit troops to fight Hamas on behalf of an American-led administration in Gaza. Trump's past foreign policy has centered on reducing US military involvement in the Middle East, and withdrawing troops from Afghanistan, Syria, and Iraq. The idea that he would commit American forces to secure Gaza for years contradicts his own foreign policy stance.
There is no indication that Hamas would voluntarily cede control or accept any external governance structure. Instead, it has vowed to resist displacement and any foreign-imposed rule over Gaza. Hamas spokesperson Hazem Qassem called Trump's idea an attempt at "occupation" and demanded an emergency Arab summit to confront any efforts to expel Palestinians from Gaza.
"Gaza is for its people, and they will not leave," Qassem said in a statement. "We call on the Arab peoples and international organizations to take strong action to reject the Trump project."
The armed group does not intend to relinquish control or accept an imposed settlement.
The Arab Situation
Trump's proposal to relocate Gaza's 2 million residents to other Arab countries faces near-universal rejection. Egypt and Jordan, the two countries most frequently mentioned in past discussions about potential refugee resettlement, have strongly opposed any such plan.
Jordan is home to a large Palestinian population already. Its King Abdullah has repeatedly warned that any forced displacement of Palestinians from Gaza would threaten his country's stability. Many in Jordan believe that resettling Palestinians will lead Israel to annex the occupied West Bank.
Egyptian President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi has rejected the idea of taking in Gazan refugees, fearing that it would not only introduce Hamas-linked security threats into the Sinai Peninsula but also set a precedent for permanent displacement.
Even wealthy Gulf nations, such as Saudi Arabia and the UAE, have shown no willingness to take in large numbers of displaced Palestinians. The Trump plan has no regional support.
Saudi Arabia has already dismissed Trump's proposal. In recent months, Saudi officials have tied any future normalisation of relations with Israel to a concrete plan toward Palestinian statehood. Trump's plan contradicts that goal, making it unlikely that Saudi Arabia would engage with it.
-
Opinion | Is The Iran-US War Talk Ready To Be Retired?
As Tehran teeters without a vision to guide it, realism doesn't appear to be trumping Washington's idealism. The Iran-US understanding is long overdue, and still, the world will benefit from it whenever it happens.
-
Exclusive: India Gets Taste Of Satellite-Based Internet During Myanmar Quake Ops
Marking a huge leap, an Indian team set up a OneWeb Eutelsat terminal in Myanmar's Mandalay to communicate with the base in New Delhi.
-
Opinion | No, Satyajit Ray Is Not Your 'Renaissance Man'
Often, posthumous or belated recognitions from the state and society seek to camouflage uncomfortable truths - truths that these very awardees spoke before they were to speak no more.
-
Opinion | Upstarts Or Startups? Why Piyush Goyal Is Not Entirely Wrong
Cutting-edge entrepreneurship is more about adventurous ambition than just growth. There must be a passion for novelty, not mere get-rich-quick ideas.
-
Trump Tariffs: The Surprise Upside For India
The impact of the tariffs on competing economies is an aspect that may end up benefiting India, sources said
-
How Trump "Liberation Day" Tariffs May Impact India And The Silver Lining
Gripped by a stark frenzy, the world could see an economic meltdown due to Trump's reciprocal tariffs, especially India - "one of the highest tariffing nations".
-
Opinion | Aurangzeb, The Ghosts Of History, And The Politics of Remembrance
The ideological battle unfolding today, whether over Aurangzeb or the broader legacy of Islamic rule, reflects the interplay between history and nationalism.
-
Blog | Love You, But I'll Sleep At Mine: On Couples Who 'Live Apart Together'
It is not a we-need-a-break situation, or some elite fad (although, let us be honest, it does require some financial flexibility). 'Living apart together' is a conscious decision to be together, but not 'too' together.
-
Opinion | Why Does Your AI 'Ghibli' Look So Terrible? Because It Is
What happens when AI conjures art out of thin air while completely isolating the user from the process? You get what is, essentially, just an artefact, minus the artistry. A hunk of butter that's all hunk and no butter.
-
Opinion | Alliance Calling: AIADMK-BJP May Have Finally Learnt A Hard Lesson
An alliance between the AIADMK and the BJP isn't an easy thing to achieve, even with Annamalai finally taming his aggression. But it's not entirely impossible either.
-
News Updates
-
Featured
-
More Links
-
Follow Us On