Khartoum: Something was missing when thousands rallied at a Khartoum-area football field for the Communist Party's first outdoor meeting in years - there was no tear gas, and there were no beatings.
In a tenuous political opening since the second half of April, other opposition parties, including Reform Now and Sudanese Congress, have also drawn large crowds without being dispersed by Sudan's security forces.
"There is an opening," says Siddig Yousif, 82, a member of the communists' central committee.
"Probably in our next rally they will stop us."
"It is a political game," Shafie says.
The regime of President Omar al-Bashir, which took power 25 years ago in an Islamist-backed coup, has faced mounting challenges since the separation of South Sudan three years ago.
Wars and unrest spread to about half of the country's 18 states, and internal divisions surfaced in Bashir's National Congress Party (NCP).
Those demonstrations made clear the urgent need for reform, which Bashir addressed in January when he appealed for a broad national political dialogue and "renaissance" focused on peace.
Laws restrict freedom
"Now parties are free to hold their rallies outside their headquarters," and banned newspapers can resume publishing, Bashir's chief assistant Ibrahim Ghandour said in a March interview.
But Yousif and other critics say there cannot be genuine freedom while laws restricting liberties remain on the books.
Chief among these is the right for security agents to detain people for more than four months without judicial review.
Yousif says that by allowing some rallies, the government has only created a perception of new freedoms.
"It is a deception," he says. "They can arrest us at any time."
Adding to the uncertainty, Bashir in mid-April decreed that parties need permission for gatherings.
The communists went ahead anyway late last month, holding their first public meeting since elections in 2010.
Authorities didn't interfere "but according to the law, that is an unlawful gathering," said Yousif.
He represents the communists in an alliance of 16 parties which refuses dialogue until certain conditions are met.
They seek the abolition of laws restricting liberties, and say peaceful discussions can only occur after a ceasefire with rebels in the Darfur, South Kordofan and Blue Nile regions.
A national dialogue must not only be among political parties, Yousif says. It has to include non-governmental groups, tribal leaders and others "on equal basis" ahead of a transitional government leading to free elections.
European Union ambassador Tomas Ulicny told a Europe Day celebration last Wednesday that a successful dialogue must be inclusive.
Without civil society, youth, and armed movements who renounce violence, it risks becoming consultations among "traditional stakeholders", Ulicny said.
Another Western diplomat, referring to Sudan's wars, told AFP: "How can you have a national dialogue when you're fighting half your people?"
The opposition alliance boycotted an early-April meeting between Bashir and dozens of political parties preparing for the dialogue.
Those joining the talks included the Popular Congress led by veteran Islamist Hassan al-Turabi, the Umma party of Sadiq al-Mahdi who was overthrown by Bashir, and Reform Now founded by NCP dissident Ghazi Salahuddin Atabani in December.
Yousif says they are only talking about sharing power, not how to address the country's problems.
"They didn't even, up till now, say what is the dialogue about," says Yousif, who has been jailed by successive regimes including Bashir's.
'A real change'
Political scientist Shafie says that while the parties try to hold a dialogue among themselves, nothing is being done to address the problems of Sudan's people.
Those are people like Assem Yousif, 35, an economics graduate who can only find work as a taxi driver.
"The problem is the ordinary people in Sudan are not on the politicians' agenda," he says.
They are people like Hajer Khaled, a mother of five.
"Is this dialogue going to improve our lives?" she asks. "If not, we don't care about it."
That is why the pace of the dialogue must quicken, says a senior member of a party which has joined the process that might lead to a coalition government.
Bashir himself is pushing for "a real change" because he realises the country is collapsing, the politician said, adding that Sudan's powerful security apparatus is resisting.
Even if Bashir is serious about reform, not everyone in the NCP is, and parties talking with the government are also split about how to approach the dialogue, says Shafie.
But Yousif does not believe Bashir is sincere.
The president is wanted by the International Criminal Court in The Hague for war crimes allegedly committed in Darfur.
His regime has a debt of more than $40 billion, much of it in arrears, and has been under American sanctions since 1997.
"I think he wants a solution for the problems they are facing... a small change which can preserve the government" and its interests while winning foreign acceptance, Yousif says.
"If the international community supports them, that will be against the interests of the Sudanese people."
In a tenuous political opening since the second half of April, other opposition parties, including Reform Now and Sudanese Congress, have also drawn large crowds without being dispersed by Sudan's security forces.
"There is an opening," says Siddig Yousif, 82, a member of the communists' central committee.
"Probably in our next rally they will stop us."
Advertisement
"It is a political game," Shafie says.
Advertisement
The regime of President Omar al-Bashir, which took power 25 years ago in an Islamist-backed coup, has faced mounting challenges since the separation of South Sudan three years ago.
Advertisement
Wars and unrest spread to about half of the country's 18 states, and internal divisions surfaced in Bashir's National Congress Party (NCP).
Advertisement
Those demonstrations made clear the urgent need for reform, which Bashir addressed in January when he appealed for a broad national political dialogue and "renaissance" focused on peace.
Advertisement
Laws restrict freedom
"Now parties are free to hold their rallies outside their headquarters," and banned newspapers can resume publishing, Bashir's chief assistant Ibrahim Ghandour said in a March interview.
But Yousif and other critics say there cannot be genuine freedom while laws restricting liberties remain on the books.
Chief among these is the right for security agents to detain people for more than four months without judicial review.
Yousif says that by allowing some rallies, the government has only created a perception of new freedoms.
"It is a deception," he says. "They can arrest us at any time."
Adding to the uncertainty, Bashir in mid-April decreed that parties need permission for gatherings.
The communists went ahead anyway late last month, holding their first public meeting since elections in 2010.
Authorities didn't interfere "but according to the law, that is an unlawful gathering," said Yousif.
He represents the communists in an alliance of 16 parties which refuses dialogue until certain conditions are met.
They seek the abolition of laws restricting liberties, and say peaceful discussions can only occur after a ceasefire with rebels in the Darfur, South Kordofan and Blue Nile regions.
A national dialogue must not only be among political parties, Yousif says. It has to include non-governmental groups, tribal leaders and others "on equal basis" ahead of a transitional government leading to free elections.
European Union ambassador Tomas Ulicny told a Europe Day celebration last Wednesday that a successful dialogue must be inclusive.
Without civil society, youth, and armed movements who renounce violence, it risks becoming consultations among "traditional stakeholders", Ulicny said.
Another Western diplomat, referring to Sudan's wars, told AFP: "How can you have a national dialogue when you're fighting half your people?"
The opposition alliance boycotted an early-April meeting between Bashir and dozens of political parties preparing for the dialogue.
Those joining the talks included the Popular Congress led by veteran Islamist Hassan al-Turabi, the Umma party of Sadiq al-Mahdi who was overthrown by Bashir, and Reform Now founded by NCP dissident Ghazi Salahuddin Atabani in December.
Yousif says they are only talking about sharing power, not how to address the country's problems.
"They didn't even, up till now, say what is the dialogue about," says Yousif, who has been jailed by successive regimes including Bashir's.
'A real change'
Political scientist Shafie says that while the parties try to hold a dialogue among themselves, nothing is being done to address the problems of Sudan's people.
Those are people like Assem Yousif, 35, an economics graduate who can only find work as a taxi driver.
"The problem is the ordinary people in Sudan are not on the politicians' agenda," he says.
They are people like Hajer Khaled, a mother of five.
"Is this dialogue going to improve our lives?" she asks. "If not, we don't care about it."
That is why the pace of the dialogue must quicken, says a senior member of a party which has joined the process that might lead to a coalition government.
Bashir himself is pushing for "a real change" because he realises the country is collapsing, the politician said, adding that Sudan's powerful security apparatus is resisting.
Even if Bashir is serious about reform, not everyone in the NCP is, and parties talking with the government are also split about how to approach the dialogue, says Shafie.
But Yousif does not believe Bashir is sincere.
The president is wanted by the International Criminal Court in The Hague for war crimes allegedly committed in Darfur.
His regime has a debt of more than $40 billion, much of it in arrears, and has been under American sanctions since 1997.
"I think he wants a solution for the problems they are facing... a small change which can preserve the government" and its interests while winning foreign acceptance, Yousif says.
"If the international community supports them, that will be against the interests of the Sudanese people."
COMMENTS
Advertisement
Biden Cancels Another $1.2 Billion In Student Debt As Vote Nears AAP To Fight Haryana Polls Solo, Will Contest All 90 Assembly Seats Biden Told Privately By Ex-Speaker Nancy Pelosi He Cannot Win: Report World's Largest Isolated Tribe Makes Rare Appearance In New Footage Barack Obama Wants Joe Biden To Pull Out Of US Presidential Race: Report Why BJP Lost Lok Sabha Polls In Uttar Pradesh - 6 Reasons In Party Report Comedy Legend Bob Newhart Dead At 94: Publicist Israeli Strike Kills Field Commander In Elite Hezbollah Unit: Report Delhi-San Francisco Air India Flight Diverted To Russia After Engine Glitch Track Latest News Live on NDTV.com and get news updates from India and around the world.