A Libyan man investigates the inside of the US Consulate after an attack that killed four Americans, including Ambassador Chris Stevens, on the night of September 11, 2012, in Benghazi, Libya. (AP Photo)
Washington:
A federal judge has refused to dismiss charges against a suspected Libyan terrorist charged in the 2012 Benghazi attacks that killed the US Ambassador and three other Americans.
Lawyers for Ahmed Abu Khattala had asked a judge to throw out all but one charge in an 18-count indictment.
They argued that the indictment was overly broad and vague and that the Justice Department had overreached in charging Khattala with crimes that had occurred abroad, rather than in the United States.
But US District Judge Christopher R. Cooper rejected those arguments in a 49-page opinion dated Wednesday, though he did ask for additional arguments on two of the counts before ruling on those charges.
The judge said that while Supreme Court decisions have limited the extraterritorial reach of federal statutes, there are nonetheless situations in which criminal laws can be applied overseas.
Khattala was captured by US special forces in a June 2014 nighttime raid in Libya and brought to the US to face charges in the Sept. 11-12 attacks on a State Department compound in Benghazi and a nearby CIA annex. The attacks killed four Americans, including Chris Stevens, the US ambassador to Libya.
He is awaiting trial in federal court in Washington on charges including providing material support to terrorists, murder of an internationally protected person and malicious destruction of federal property.
Defense lawyers have also urged Cooper to return Khattala to Libya as a sanction for what they call their client's illegal capture and interrogation, which took place aboard a Navy ship that brought him to the US
Cooper's 49-page opinion did not address those arguments.
Lawyers for Ahmed Abu Khattala had asked a judge to throw out all but one charge in an 18-count indictment.
They argued that the indictment was overly broad and vague and that the Justice Department had overreached in charging Khattala with crimes that had occurred abroad, rather than in the United States.
But US District Judge Christopher R. Cooper rejected those arguments in a 49-page opinion dated Wednesday, though he did ask for additional arguments on two of the counts before ruling on those charges.
The judge said that while Supreme Court decisions have limited the extraterritorial reach of federal statutes, there are nonetheless situations in which criminal laws can be applied overseas.
Khattala was captured by US special forces in a June 2014 nighttime raid in Libya and brought to the US to face charges in the Sept. 11-12 attacks on a State Department compound in Benghazi and a nearby CIA annex. The attacks killed four Americans, including Chris Stevens, the US ambassador to Libya.
He is awaiting trial in federal court in Washington on charges including providing material support to terrorists, murder of an internationally protected person and malicious destruction of federal property.
Defense lawyers have also urged Cooper to return Khattala to Libya as a sanction for what they call their client's illegal capture and interrogation, which took place aboard a Navy ship that brought him to the US
Cooper's 49-page opinion did not address those arguments.
Track Latest News Live on NDTV.com and get news updates from India and around the world
