San Jose, California: A judge on Thursday said she would require consumers suing Google over its Android smartphone operating system to submit more factual details in order for an antitrust lawsuit to proceed, at a time when the Internet search company faces increased regulatory pressure.
The lawsuit filed earlier this year says Google Inc requires Android handset manufacturers such as Samsung Electronics Co Ltd to restrict competing apps like Microsoft Corp's Bing search, partly by making Google's own apps the default.
The consumers claim these deals raise smartphone prices, because Google's rivals are not allowed to compete for premium placement on phone screens.
At a hearing on Thursday in a San Jose, California, federal court, U.S. District Judge Beth Labson Freeman questioned whether that theory is too vague for the lawsuit to proceed.
"The speculative nature of the damages is really quite concerning to me," Freeman said.
The judge said she would most likely dismiss the lawsuit, but give the plaintiffs an opportunity to revise it with additional facts to try to proceed on some legal claims.
Last month, the European Parliament overwhelmingly passed a non-binding resolution urging antitrust authorities to break up Google. The lawmakers called on the European Commission to consider proposals to unbundle search engines from other commercial services.
Google argues in its court filings that the proposed class action should be dismissed because consumers still are free to use the other apps. The plaintiffs counter that most consumers either do not know how to switch default settings, or will not go to the trouble.
Should Freeman ultimately allow the proposed class action to proceed, plaintiffs' attorneys would be allowed to delve into internal Google emails and contracts with smartphone companies, and could interview Google executives under oath.
In court on Thursday, Google attorney John Schmidtlein said the case should be dismissed because plaintiffs had not produced any evidence that handset makers actually wanted to use a different search engine.
In response, plaintiff attorney Robert Lopez countered said consumers should be allowed to examine Google's documents to learn those details.
But Freeman said U.S. law mandates that plaintiffs present enough facts in their lawsuit "before I open the floodgates" to expensive discovery.
The case is Gary Feitelson and Daniel McKee, on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated vs. Google Inc, in U.S. District Court, Northern District of California No. 14-2007.
The lawsuit filed earlier this year says Google Inc requires Android handset manufacturers such as Samsung Electronics Co Ltd to restrict competing apps like Microsoft Corp's Bing search, partly by making Google's own apps the default.
The consumers claim these deals raise smartphone prices, because Google's rivals are not allowed to compete for premium placement on phone screens.
"The speculative nature of the damages is really quite concerning to me," Freeman said.
Advertisement
Last month, the European Parliament overwhelmingly passed a non-binding resolution urging antitrust authorities to break up Google. The lawmakers called on the European Commission to consider proposals to unbundle search engines from other commercial services.
Advertisement
Should Freeman ultimately allow the proposed class action to proceed, plaintiffs' attorneys would be allowed to delve into internal Google emails and contracts with smartphone companies, and could interview Google executives under oath.
Advertisement
In response, plaintiff attorney Robert Lopez countered said consumers should be allowed to examine Google's documents to learn those details.
Advertisement
The case is Gary Feitelson and Daniel McKee, on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated vs. Google Inc, in U.S. District Court, Northern District of California No. 14-2007.
Advertisement
© Thomson Reuters 2014
COMMENTS
Advertisement
Epic Games Launches Its iOS App Store in Europe, Brings Fortnite Back to the Platform After Four Years WhatsApp Introduces Giphy Sticker Collection, Custom Sticker Maker and More Features US Court Calls Google Monopolist, Says It Violates Competition Law Kolkata Rape-Murder: Fractures, 150 mg Semen, Other Claims Denied By Cops Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah To Be Prosecuted In Land Scam Case Life On Earth Originates From One Ancestor, Older Than Previously Believed 17 Palestinians Killed In Israeli Strike On Gaza Amid Raging War Tips For Navigating The Ivy League Admission Process Watch: Air Force, Army's Daring Paradrop Of World's 1st Portable Hospital Track Latest News Live on NDTV.com and get news updates from India and around the world.