The robe came off.
A Michigan judge, growing increasingly frustrated with a defendant who was talking back to him, stormed down from his bench and rushed to help subdue the man as he resisted being handcuffed.
Though the incident took place in December, video footage of the scuffle was published this week on Mlive.com. It showed a rare instance of a judge physically intervening in a courtroom situation - something that at least one of the Michigan judge's colleagues said was justified in this case.
The hearing was about Larson's alleged violation of a personal protection order against the woman, who in the video is seated at a table next to Larson but whose face is blurred.
"It's like 'Fatal Attraction' kind of stuff that I warned you about last time," McBain said, referring to the 1987 film in which Glenn Close plays an obsessive stalker. "I told you to just leave her alone. She was a classmate of yours. She apparently has no interest in - "
That seemed to irritate McBain, whose voice became noticeably sharper as he responded: "You know what? I told you to leave her alone. And apparently that didn't get through loud and clear. So today, you're going to jail for three days."
As Larson continued interrupting the judge, McBain upped his jail sentence.
A court officer seen in the video told Mlive.com that as he tried to take Larson into custody, the defendant "tensed up" and tried to fight him. Larson and the officer, identified by Mlive.com as Jared Schultz, struggled as Larson continued to point and talk to the woman.
"Tase his a-- right now!" McBain shouted, as he threw off his judge's robe, ran over to the two men and then physically helped pin Larson to the ground. Throughout the scuffle, Larson is heard cursing periodically.
This was not the first time McBain's comments as a judge have made the news. In 2014, he told a convicted murderer that he hoped she died in prison, Mlive.com reported.
"Sometimes, I think a judge needs a little fire in the right kind of cases," McBain told the news site at the time.
McBain did not respond to an email sent to his office Friday. A woman who answered the phone for the Jackson County courts system said the judge was not taking calls regarding the video.
"There is one thing I don't tolerate is disruptions in my courtroom," McBain told Mlive.com, adding that Larson was "totally disturbing the decorum of the court."
McBain told the news site that it was the first time he has had to physically restrain someone in his courtroom.
Jackson County Chief Circuit Judge Thomas Wilson told the Associated Press that McBain's actions were allowable.
"A judge has the power to take whatever action is necessary to maintain order in the courtroom," Wilson told the AP.
According to Mlive.com, Larson was accused of stalking the woman for about a year but blamed his behavior on her:
"Obsessed" for reasons she did not know, he was a high school classmate of the woman, and sent her 22 Facebook messages after McBain signed the order in August 2015 and before the December hearing. "He's not leaving me alone," the woman, now 22, told the judge.
Since the courtroom incident, Larson again violated the protection order in July, after he sent the woman 20 friend requests on Instagram, according to a detailed case report obtained by The Washington Post.
The woman went to Larson's Instagram and discovered a video he had made with her name as the title, the report said. In the video, Larson reportedly referred to the protection order and said "if he can't have her, no one can," implying that the two had a dating relationship. The woman told police the two of them had never had a dating relationship and that their only connection was that they had gone to the same school, according to the report.
Larson has since been charged with aggravated stalking and is scheduled to appear in court again Dec. 2, according to Jackson County court records.
Mlive.com reported that McBain has recused himself from Larson's cases pertaining to the protection order after witnessing his behavior in the courtroom.
Formerly a prosecuting attorney, McBain was elected to the Jackson County Circuit Court bench in 2002, according to his bio on a county webpage. In 2007, he was appointed chief judge pro-tempore in the Jackson County Circuit Court.
© 2016 The Washington Post
(This story has not been edited by NDTV staff and is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)
A Michigan judge, growing increasingly frustrated with a defendant who was talking back to him, stormed down from his bench and rushed to help subdue the man as he resisted being handcuffed.
Though the incident took place in December, video footage of the scuffle was published this week on Mlive.com. It showed a rare instance of a judge physically intervening in a courtroom situation - something that at least one of the Michigan judge's colleagues said was justified in this case.
The hearing was about Larson's alleged violation of a personal protection order against the woman, who in the video is seated at a table next to Larson but whose face is blurred.
Advertisement
"It's like 'Fatal Attraction' kind of stuff that I warned you about last time," McBain said, referring to the 1987 film in which Glenn Close plays an obsessive stalker. "I told you to just leave her alone. She was a classmate of yours. She apparently has no interest in - "
Advertisement
That seemed to irritate McBain, whose voice became noticeably sharper as he responded: "You know what? I told you to leave her alone. And apparently that didn't get through loud and clear. So today, you're going to jail for three days."
Advertisement
As Larson continued interrupting the judge, McBain upped his jail sentence.
Advertisement
A court officer seen in the video told Mlive.com that as he tried to take Larson into custody, the defendant "tensed up" and tried to fight him. Larson and the officer, identified by Mlive.com as Jared Schultz, struggled as Larson continued to point and talk to the woman.
Advertisement
"Tase his a-- right now!" McBain shouted, as he threw off his judge's robe, ran over to the two men and then physically helped pin Larson to the ground. Throughout the scuffle, Larson is heard cursing periodically.
This was not the first time McBain's comments as a judge have made the news. In 2014, he told a convicted murderer that he hoped she died in prison, Mlive.com reported.
"Sometimes, I think a judge needs a little fire in the right kind of cases," McBain told the news site at the time.
McBain did not respond to an email sent to his office Friday. A woman who answered the phone for the Jackson County courts system said the judge was not taking calls regarding the video.
"There is one thing I don't tolerate is disruptions in my courtroom," McBain told Mlive.com, adding that Larson was "totally disturbing the decorum of the court."
McBain told the news site that it was the first time he has had to physically restrain someone in his courtroom.
Jackson County Chief Circuit Judge Thomas Wilson told the Associated Press that McBain's actions were allowable.
"A judge has the power to take whatever action is necessary to maintain order in the courtroom," Wilson told the AP.
According to Mlive.com, Larson was accused of stalking the woman for about a year but blamed his behavior on her:
"Obsessed" for reasons she did not know, he was a high school classmate of the woman, and sent her 22 Facebook messages after McBain signed the order in August 2015 and before the December hearing. "He's not leaving me alone," the woman, now 22, told the judge.
Since the courtroom incident, Larson again violated the protection order in July, after he sent the woman 20 friend requests on Instagram, according to a detailed case report obtained by The Washington Post.
The woman went to Larson's Instagram and discovered a video he had made with her name as the title, the report said. In the video, Larson reportedly referred to the protection order and said "if he can't have her, no one can," implying that the two had a dating relationship. The woman told police the two of them had never had a dating relationship and that their only connection was that they had gone to the same school, according to the report.
Larson has since been charged with aggravated stalking and is scheduled to appear in court again Dec. 2, according to Jackson County court records.
Mlive.com reported that McBain has recused himself from Larson's cases pertaining to the protection order after witnessing his behavior in the courtroom.
Formerly a prosecuting attorney, McBain was elected to the Jackson County Circuit Court bench in 2002, according to his bio on a county webpage. In 2007, he was appointed chief judge pro-tempore in the Jackson County Circuit Court.
© 2016 The Washington Post
(This story has not been edited by NDTV staff and is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)
COMMENTS
Advertisement
South Africa Scripts History, Gets First Woman Chief Justice 21 Of 661 High Court Judges Appointed Since 2018 Belong To Scheduled Caste: Centre 10 Additional Delhi, Bombay High Court Judges Made Permanent President Appoints 6 New Governors, Reshuffles 3 Others Teen Rapes Sister After Watching Porn, Strangles Her Before Their Mother 3 Students Dead After Flooding In Delhi Coaching Centre Basement Students Killed In Flooding At Delhi Coaching Centre Were UPSC Aspirants Chief Justice Says Marked "Shift" In Approach Towards Disability President Droupadi Murmu Appoints New Governors In 9 States Track Latest News Live on NDTV.com and get news updates from India and around the world.